Connect with us

BUSINESS

Rubio Warns the ICC and Puts Allies on the Clock

Marco Rubio’s Federalist Society ICC warning restates a sanctions campaign that gives allied court members until April to yield.

Published

on

Secretary of State Marco Rubio told conservative lawyers in Washington on Nov. 13 that the United States would not bow to International Criminal Court orders. If the court tried to enforce what he called paper decrees on Americans, he said, Washington would answer as the Roman general Pompey did: “Stop quoting laws to men with swords.”

The line came 35 days after the United States listed the court itself on the Treasury sanctions roster, with a wind-down for U.S. firms that ends April 7, 2027. The addressees are governments that sit in the court and host American troops.

The Olson Lecture Aimed Past the Hague

Rubio spoke at 5 p.m. at the Mayflower Hotel in the Barbara K. Olson Memorial Lecture, the Federalist Society’s marquee slot at its National Lawyers Convention. His daughter Daniella Rubio, a third-year student at the University of Virginia School of Law, introduced him. The State Department posted his full remarks at the Mayflower Hotel the same night.

He holds both jobs at once. The Senate confirmed him 99-0 on Jan. 20, 2025, as the 72nd secretary of state, and he was sworn in the next day; he also runs the National Security Council as the president’s national security advisor. He opened with a joke from election night on Nov. 3, when a congressman said Republicans needed to lawyer up, then spent the rest of the hour arguing that elections do not, by themselves, decide what lawyers treat as law.

He walked the room through the Federalist Society’s origin in 1982 and treated that history as a brief for power beyond statutes. “Elections decide who holds office for a season,” he said. “But elections, they do not decide by themselves what our institutions teach or what our lawyers believe.” He then moved that claim onto foreign policy and said the phrase international law had been “invoked against nearly every major foreign policy decision or action of this administration.”

The examples he chose were not Hague case files. He defended orders to sink cartel boats in the Caribbean and said the founding chief prosecutor of what he called “the fake and illegitimate International Criminal Court” had accused the United States of crimes against humanity. He cited the capture of Nicolás Maduro, Venezuela’s former president, and he said groups including the ACLU had asked the United Nations to investigate ICE. When the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, he added, UN human rights experts denounced the ruling as a breach of binding international duties.

“None of this has anything to do with any real higher standard of justice,” he said. “It is a function of the people who control the official organs of global governance.” For that elite, he said, international law is “an instrument to advance their interests under the pretense of universal principles.”

Why the Sanctions Clock Matters More Than the Quote

The ICC passage was the hard edge of that argument, and it was not a hypothetical. “That’s why, earlier this year, President Trump made the unprecedented decision to sanction the fake International Criminal Court,” Rubio said, “an unelected world tribunal, which claims to supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those who never signed up for it.”

They can certainly try, I would say. But if they’re foolish enough to try to enforce their paper decrees on Americans, our answer will probably be the same as the Roman general, Pompey, when he said to those who were trying to invoke their cities’ charters against his legions. He said, “Stop quoting laws to men with swords.”

Marco Rubio, Secretary of State, Barbara K. Olson Memorial Lecture, Mayflower Hotel

The court has no police force of its own. It needs member states to arrest suspects, freeze assets, and keep the lights on. The United States never became a party to the Rome Statute, so the practical question is not whether ICC officers will land in Virginia. It is whether a British, Dutch, German, or Japanese government will treat an ICC request involving an American, or an American partner, as a legal duty.

The live warrants that produced the U.S. campaign are not American indictments. The White House order that opened this round names arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, and it cites an ICC investigation that reached U.S. personnel in Afghanistan. The court has not charged Americans. The swords line still functions as a warning to capitals that might arrest a U.S. partner while remaining in the court and under the U.S. security umbrella.

“To submit to the sterile vision of radical judges or soulless global bureaucrats would be to betray who we are, to betray ourselves,” Rubio said. He folded that foreign-policy claim into a domestic one, pairing “activist courts who seek to govern by injunction” with the Hague tribunal, and he told the lawyers that law at home and abroad was being used “to weaken the United States.”

April 7 Is When the Licenses Run Out

On Oct. 9, Rubio announced that the United States would ban transactions with this rogue court, “cutting off their resources and crippling its ability to operate.” The ICC was designated under section 1(a)(ii)(A) of Executive Order 14203. “Either the ICC will end its threats, or we will end the ICC,” he said. “We expect our allies, many of whom are part of the ICC and that rely on American servicemembers for their defense, to rein in the court.” If they do not, he said, the United States will “continue its campaign to dismantle the ICC, brick by brick.”

That listing was the end of a 20-month climb, not the start of one. President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14203 on Feb. 6, 2025, and put Prosecutor Karim Khan in the annex. Over the next year and a half Rubio designated 13 more people and three organizations, including, in August 2026, the court’s president, Judge Tomoko Akane of Japan. On Oct. 9 the institution itself went onto the Treasury Department’s Specially Designated Nationals list, the roster used for cartels, terrorist groups, and weapons proliferators.

THE DESIGNATION LADDER

DateStepTarget
Feb. 6, 2025Executive Order 14203Prosecutor Karim Khan
2025 through August 2026Further designations13 more people and 3 organizations, including President Tomoko Akane
Oct. 9, 2026SDN listingThe ICC as an institution
Oct. 13, 2026Preliminary injunctionLimited shield for some U.S. advocates’ speech
April 7, 2027Wind-down license endsRemaining U.S. commercial ties must stop

OFAC issued general licenses with the Oct. 9 listing, including one that lets firms wind down existing contracts with the court until April 7, 2027, 180 days after the designation. Outside those licenses, U.S. persons may not provide funds, goods, or services to the court. John Balouziyeh, a sanctions lawyer at Curtis, Mallet-Prevost, Colt and Mosle, wrote that willful violations can bring criminal prosecution and up to 20 years in prison. Once the wind-down lapses, he noted, every U.S. bank, vendor, and software firm outside the leftover licenses has to cut a court that holds defendants and runs trials.

Rubio said the delay was deliberate. Washington had “exercised discretion and deferred this designation out of respect for our relationships,” he wrote on Oct. 9, “in hopes that the ICC would change course or would otherwise be restrained by States Parties.” He still held out “hope for a diplomatic solution” and said the action was structured so member states could “negotiate and present a solution.” The April 7 date is that interval, written as a license.

The Hague Invasion Act Never Left the Books

The Pompey flourish sounds like a new doctrine. The statute behind it is 24 years old. In 2002 Congress passed the American Servicemembers’ Protection Act, a law whose stated aim is to protect United States military personnel and U.S. officials from a court the United States never joined. The act authorizes the president to use “all means necessary and appropriate” to free U.S. or allied personnel detained by, or at the request of, the ICC. Critics nicknamed it the Hague Invasion Act because that language can include force at the court’s seat in the Netherlands.

The Feb. 6, 2025 order leans on that statute. Trump declared a national emergency over ICC jurisdiction after finding that the court had “engaged in illegitimate and baseless actions targeting America and our close ally Israel.” The order says the court has no jurisdiction over the United States or Israel, names the Netanyahu and Gallant warrants, and states that the United States “expects our allies to oppose any ICC actions against the United States, Israel, or any other ally of the United States that has not consented to ICC jurisdiction.”

Protected persons under the order include U.S. troops, officials, and other U.S. persons, plus citizens of NATO members and major non-NATO allies that are not parties to the Rome Statute. Property of designated persons is blocked. Their entry, and that of immediate family, can be suspended. The first Trump term had already used a 2020 emergency order against ICC officials, which the Biden administration later revoked while still objecting to jurisdiction over U.S. personnel. The 2025 order put that fight back on a sanctions footing; the Oct. 9 listing applied it to the court as a whole.

Rubio’s speech therefore did not invent a collision with The Hague. It restated, for a domestic legal audience, a campaign that already treats cooperation with the court against “protected persons” as a national-security problem, and it did so in the vocabulary of a 2002 force statute.

Eight Allied Capitals Already Said No

The Oct. 9 statement was written as a demand on friends. The first answer from those friends was a rejection. The foreign ministers of eight countries issued a joint statement that they “regret and strongly disagree” with the sanctions and reaffirmed “continued and unwavering support” for the court.

THE EIGHT GOVERNMENTS THAT OBJECTED

  • Canada: Joined the Oct. 9 foreign ministers’ statement defending the court.
  • Denmark: Signed the same joint protest the day of the SDN listing.
  • France: Joined the eight-country text and remains an ICC member.
  • Germany: Joined the protest; U.S. forces remain stationed on German soil.
  • Italy: Signed the Oct. 9 statement with the other seven.
  • Japan: Signed the protest; its national, Tomoko Akane, is the sanctioned court president.
  • Netherlands: Hosts the court in The Hague and signed the joint text.
  • United Kingdom: Joined the eight-country statement the day Washington listed the institution.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres condemned the listing of the court “as an institution,” called himself “deeply alarmed” at the effect on its work, and described the step as a serious blow to international criminal justice. The ICC called the measures “an assault on the rule of law and on the very foundations of the international legal order.”

Japan is the awkward case inside that list. Akane, the first Japanese national to preside at the court, was designated in August 2026 and has already been barred from entering the United States; she addressed the UN General Assembly by video. On Nov. 6, a cross-party delegation of Japanese lawmakers met her in The Hague and heard her ask member countries to keep supporting the tribunal. Yasue Funayama, who co-led the group with former Defense Minister Gen Nakatani, said Japan should “say what must be said to the United States because we are allies.” Former Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda, on the same trip, said Japan “should not waver when the ICC is facing a crisis.”

Those governments now sit in a bind the speech was built to tighten. They fund and staff a court Washington has listed like a cartel. They also rely on U.S. forces, U.S. intelligence, and U.S. market access. Rubio’s Oct. 9 text told them to “rein in the court.” His Nov. 13 lecture told a room of American lawyers that paper from that court would be met with swords. The interval between those two statements is the April 7 license.

What the Manhattan Injunction Does Not Stop

Four days after the SDN listing, the campaign hit a U.S. courtroom. On Oct. 13, Judge Jesse Furman of the Southern District of New York, ruling in Democracy for the Arab World Now v. Trump, granted a preliminary injunction in substantial part. He held that the order’s ban on providing “services” to designated persons is likely unconstitutional as applied to the plaintiffs, because it restricts their speech by content, and he blocked civil and criminal penalties against them for the advocacy described in their complaint.

He did not strike the order off the books. A bank, he noted, has no First Amendment right to process the court’s payments. An American advocacy group does have a right to send legal analysis to the prosecutor. The distinction leaves the Oct. 9 listing in force against financial firms, software vendors, and other U.S. persons who are not bringing a speech claim. The IEEPA argument, that a treaty-court investigation is not an “unusual and extraordinary threat,” remains for the merits.

Balouziyeh’s point in early November was that the decisive fight is therefore still in Manhattan, not in The Hague. If a court holds that IEEPA cannot underwrite this emergency, the designations collapse. If it holds the other way, other states get a working model for cutting a treaty court off from banks and cloud software. Rubio did not mention Furman on Nov. 13. He told a hall of lawyers that international law is an elite instrument and that decrees from the ICC would be answered with swords, a month after a federal judge told the same administration it could not punish some American lawyers for talking to that court.

The speech also reached past the ICC. Rubio said the “spirit of Marx” survived the Soviet collapse in doctrines that “would subordinate the national will to the menial consensus of the world,” and that “the radicals of our time seek to abolish the distinctions between nations themselves.” He called America “a nation of irrepressible ambition” and said the Revolution itself grew in part from anger at British limits on westward expansion. That is the larger brief he was selling to the Federalist Society: that U.S. courts, law schools, and diplomats should treat international rules as politics, and that the conservative legal movement’s long march through domestic institutions is the template for that fight abroad.

U.S. firms that still service the court have until April 7, 2027, to finish those contracts, unless Washington issues a new license or the member states produce the deal Rubio said he still wants.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending