BUSINESS
Adani’s Tarali Cost Cut Shrinks a Tiger Reserve Levy
Adani Green cut Tarali’s stated cost 99%, shrinking a Sahyadri wildlife levy after forest officers accepted a survey figure as project cost.
Adani Green Energy Ltd has restated its 1,500 MW Tarali pumped storage plant in Satara at Rs 56.75 crore, a hundredth of the Rs 5,675 crore in its environmental clearance.
Maharashtra’s forest department accepted that figure, so a 4% wildlife deposit for the Sahyadri Tiger Reserve fell from Rs 227 crore to Rs 2.275 crore. The company says Rs 56.75 crore covered site surveys, not the plant. On November 6, 2026, the Union environment ministry told the state to investigate on priority.
A 1,500 MW Plant on Private Land, Inside a Deemed Zone
Tarali is an open-loop pumped storage scheme on the existing Tarali dam reservoir in Patan taluka. Water is moved between two ponds so the plant can store power and send it back to the grid when solar and wind drop off. The clearance is for 1,500 MW in six units, four of 300 MW and two of 150 MW, on 150.74 hectares of non-forest land in Nivade, Tondoshi, Kalambe and Jalu.
The ministry issued the clearance on February 11, 2025, after the Expert Appraisal Committee met on December 31, 2024. Annexure II of that letter records the estimated project cost of Rs 5,675 crore. It also sets Rs 3,934.08 lakh as capital spending on the environment plan, names 1,000 direct jobs, and runs for 13 years from the start of operations.
Work is already visible near Tondoshi. Adani Green Energy says every element sits on private land and uses no forest land, and that the site is 3.2 km from Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary. A senior Maharashtra forest officer, speaking without being named, said Koyna’s eco-sensitive zone has never been notified, so Supreme Court directions treat a 10 km belt as a deemed zone, and Tarali sits inside it.
That gap, notified buffer versus deemed belt, is the legal hinge. The company says the plant is outside the notified buffer of the tiger reserve and does not touch a tiger corridor or any notified eco-sensitive zone. The forest department has still treated it as a private project in a deemed zone, which is how a cost percentage became a conservation bill.

The Four Percent That Moves With the Cost
The State Board for Wildlife met on February 23, 2026, and put 15 conditions on the proposal. One of them required Adani Green Energy to deposit 4% of the project cost in the Sahyadri Tiger Reserve’s bank account for sanctuary conservation. On March 24, 2026, Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (Wildlife) M Srinivas Reddy, who is also the state’s chief wildlife warden, wrote to the company listing those conditions and asking for Rs 227 crore, which is 4% of Rs 5,675 crore.
A May 7, 2026, letter from the deputy director of Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary repeated the same arithmetic and the same deemed-zone finding. The 4% is not a figure written into the Wild Life (Protection) Act. Officers describe it as existing norms for private companies in an eco-sensitive zone, “up to 4%” of project cost.
HOW THE DEPOSIT IS BUILT
- The trigger: A project that needs environmental clearance and sits in a notified eco-sensitive zone, or, if none is drawn, in a 10 km belt around a sanctuary.
- The rate: Maharashtra’s wildlife board asked for 4% of the stated project cost, paid into the tiger reserve’s account.
- The split: Officers later asked for 1% up front and the remaining 3% after the National Board for Wildlife clears the file.
- The lever: Change the cost on the file and the conservation bill moves by the same percentage, without a fresh count of trees, prey or tigers.
Central wildlife rules do require a look at projects near sanctuaries. The 2012 guidance on non-forestry work in wildlife habitat, still circulated by the Maharashtra forest department, says that if a project needing environmental clearance lies in an eco-sensitive zone, or within 10 kms from its boundaries when no zone is drawn, the user agency must obtain the standing committee of the National Board for Wildlife. That is a clearance step. It is not, by itself, a 4% cash formula.
The National Board for Wildlife’s standing committee in 2021 discussed a 2% levy on projects inside protected areas and eco-sensitive zones, then stepped back from a uniform rate in favour of mitigation costs set project by project. Maharashtra’s own draft wildlife action plan has talked about 3% to 7% for some non-linear work in sanctuaries, tiger reserves and corridors. Tarali was billed at the top of the “up to 4%” band, on the full plant cost, on private land.
The levy therefore sits on the budget, not on a measured loss of habitat. That is why a restatement of cost moved the tiger-reserve bill from Rs 227 crore to Rs 2.275 crore without a new map of the ponds.
How Rs 5,675 Crore Became Rs 56.75 Crore
On September 8, 2026, Adani Green Energy chief operating officer Naresh Telgu sent Reddy a notarised affidavit. The covering line said that while Part IV of the proposal was submitted, the project cost had been taken from an analogous estimate, and asked that the figure in the affidavit be used. The affidavit itself said the cost “is considered based on analogous estimation, we considered as INR 56.75 crore.”
Rs 56.75 crore is exactly one-hundredth of Rs 5,675 crore, a 99% cut. Satara honorary wildlife warden Rohan Bhate later said the company had, “by placing a decimal in between,” written a cost 100 times smaller than the estimate in the clearance. On October 12, 2026, Reddy wrote that his office had agreed to the affidavit, had asked the government to place the project before the National Board for Wildlife’s standing committee, and wanted 1% of the new cost paid at once.
THE COST THAT SETS THE WILDLIFE BILL
| Item | Clearance, February 2025 | Affidavit, September 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Stated project cost | Rs 5,675 crore | Rs 56.75 crore |
| 4% deposit to Sahyadri Tiger Reserve | Rs 227 crore | Rs 2.275 crore |
| Paid so far | – | Rs 56.75 lakh (1%) |
| Balance after national wildlife clearance | – | Rs 1.7075 crore (3%) |
Sahyadri Tiger Reserve field director Tushar Chavan confirmed the company paid Rs 56.75 lakh into the reserve’s account, matching 1% of Rs 56.75 crore. Reddy’s October letter called that instalment Rs 0.5675 crore and the later 3% Rs 1.7075 crore, which together equal Rs 2.275 crore.
A 1,500 MW pumped storage plant at Rs 56.75 crore would cost Rs 0.0378 crore a megawatt. The Central Electricity Authority has put the average cost of new pumped storage at about Rs 6 crore a megawatt, which prices a 1,500 MW plant near Rs 9,000 crore. A forest-clearance cost-benefit note for JSW Energy’s 1,500 MW Bhavali pumped storage project, also in Maharashtra, lists Rs 9,058.09 crore. Even the environment plan inside Tarali’s own clearance, Rs 3,934.08 lakh of capital spending, sits in the same range as the entire restated “project cost.”
THE FILE FROM CLEARANCE TO PROBE
- February 11, 2025: The environment ministry grants prior environmental clearance and records the plant cost as Rs 5,675 crore.
- February 23, 2026: The State Board for Wildlife endorses the proposal with 15 conditions, including a 4% deposit to the tiger reserve.
- March 24, 2026: Reddy asks Adani Green Energy to deposit Rs 227 crore and to file an affidavit on the other 14 conditions.
- May 7, 2026: The Koyna deputy director restates that the plant lies in the deemed eco-sensitive zone and that 4% of Rs 5,675 crore is Rs 227 crore.
- September 8, 2026: Telgu files the notarised affidavit putting the cost at Rs 56.75 crore.
- October 12, 2026: Reddy accepts that figure and asks for Rs 0.5675 crore now, with Rs 1.7075 crore after national wildlife clearance.
- October 30, 2026: Bhate complains of an “incorrect cost of the project” on the Prime Minister’s grievance portal and Maharashtra’s Aaple Sarkar portal.
- November 5-6, 2026: The Koyna deputy director is told to inquire, and the Union environment ministry directs a priority investigation.
Bhate, when asked about the file, said a private project cutting through the eco-sensitive zone of a notified tiger corridor is asked to deposit up to 4% of project cost under established procedure, and that the state board had “rightfully” set Rs 227 crore. “Even a layman would understand that such a huge power project cannot happen on such a low budget,” he said, adding that an “undue concession or discount of about Rs 225 crore” should be revoked and that those found guilty should be punished.
Adani Says the Lower Figure Was Only for Surveys
Adani Green Energy, in a statement after the cost cut became public, called the charge that it had revised costs to shrink statutory dues “completely misleading.” It drew a line between the online forest and wildlife portal and the state wildlife board’s reading of the full plant.
The online proposal in the Forest/wildlife portal was solely for site investigation purposes, while SBWL (State Board for Wildlife) considered total project costs of Rs 5,675 crore. Since site investigation costs are around 1% of project costs, therefore clarification of the project Rs 56.75 crore representing solely the site investigations and survey costs, for the online proposal was provided.
Adani Green Energy Ltd spokesperson, company statement
The 2012 wildlife-habitat guidance does have a separate track for investigation and survey, and it says survey work that is a prelude to later diversion still follows the full wildlife procedure. Telgu’s affidavit, though, did not call Rs 56.75 crore a survey budget. It asked the forest department to treat that sum as “project cost.” Reddy’s October letter did exactly that, and reset the 4% on it.
The same statement said the plant is entirely on private, non-forest land, 3.2 km from Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary, outside the notified buffer of the Sahyadri Tiger Reserve, and that it “in no way impacts or fringes upon the tiger corridor or any notified Eco-Sensitive zone.” It added that the project does not divert protected area, reserve forest or notified eco-sensitive zone. Asked earlier about complaints of an incorrect cost, a group spokesperson said pumped storage has no adverse effect on downstream ecology in operations and that the smaller ponds “have a positive impact on the local ecology” by holding humidity around the flora and fauna. The spokesperson did not then answer the specific question on the revised cost.
Those location claims can all be true on a map and still leave the deemed-zone condition in place. The Koyna deputy director’s May letter had already told the company, in writing, that the standing committee of the state wildlife board had treated the plant as passing through the buffer or deemed eco-sensitive zone and had billed 4% of Rs 5,675 crore.
The Forest Officer Who Signed Off, Then Pointed Back
The live institutional fact is not that a company filed a low number. It is that the state’s senior wildlife officer accepted it as the cost for a condition his own office had already quantified at Rs 227 crore, then forwarded the file toward the National Board for Wildlife.
When contacted after the acceptance became public, Reddy said, “You should ask the company why it submitted an affidavit with a revised project cost.” He did not, in that reply, explain why his office treated the affidavit as enough to recast a condition the state board had attached to the full plant. The Union ministry’s November 6 letter put the next move back on the same department. Wildlife protection and mitigation, it said, are “primarily the responsibility of the State/UT government,” and it asked for an investigation on priority, with a reply to the complainant and intimation to the ministry.
The louder problem is that a notarised restatement was allowed to stand in for an audited estimate, and that the officer who signed the lower bill then pointed at the applicant. A decimal on a form does not collect itself. Someone in Van Bhavan had to agree that Rs 56.75 crore was the cost that would travel to Delhi.
What the Sahyadri Reserve Stands to Lose
Sahyadri is the northernmost tiger reserve in the Western Ghats, notified on 5 January 2010 by joining Chandoli National Park (317.67 sq km) and Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary (423.55 sq km). A 2012 state notification set a core of 600.12 sq km and a buffer of 565.45 sq km, a total of 1,165.57 sq km across Satara, Sangli, Kolhapur and Ratnagiri. UNESCO listed parts of this landscape as World Heritage in 2012. Koyna is also an Important Bird Area.
THE RESERVE THE DEPOSIT WAS MEANT TO FUND
- Core and buffer: 600.12 sq km of critical tiger habitat and 565.45 sq km of buffer, under the field director at Kolhapur.
- The two blocks: Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary in the north and Chandoli National Park in the south, with lateritic plateaus, or sadaa, in the mix of woodland and grass.
- The money at issue: Rs 227 crore billed, Rs 56.75 lakh received, Rs 1.7075 crore listed as due if the national board clears the plant on the revised cost.
- The corridor claim: National tiger notes describe a Western Ghats link toward Radhanagari and on toward Goa and Anshi-Dandeli; Adani Green Energy says Tarali does not fringe that corridor.
Rs 227 crore is a conservation budget large enough to fund years of protection, prey work and staff in a reserve that has had to rebuild a tiger presence after long gaps in direct evidence. Rs 2.275 crore is a rounding error on the same file. The Adani Green Tarali project cost cut wildlife deposit is the entire difference, and it was produced by a change in the denominator, not by a new wildlife study.
Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh, posting on November 13, 2026, called the restatement “a scandal of gigantic proportions” and revived the party’s demand, pending since March 2023, for a joint parliamentary committee on the Adani Group’s operations. “A project which was sanctioned last year for Rs 5,675 crore is now stated in an affidavit to have a cost of Rs 56.75 crore. It is a 99% reduction,” he wrote. That is a political demand. The file in Satara is a plainer question: which cost the 4% is allowed to sit on, and who in the forest department was entitled to swap it.
The Centre Has Pushed the Probe Onto the State
Three inquiries now sit on the same complaint. The Union environment ministry has asked the state principal chief conservator of forests (wildlife) to investigate on priority. The state forest department has opened its own probe. On November 5, 2026, the deputy director of Koyna Wildlife Sanctuary was told to inquire and to act as per rules. The National Board for Wildlife has still not considered the project. The remaining Rs 1.7075 crore is written as payable after that clearance, on the revised cost the ministry has now put under examination.
WHAT WE KNOW
- The two costs: The clearance of February 11, 2025, states Rs 5,675 crore; the September 8, 2026, affidavit states Rs 56.75 crore; Reddy accepted the second figure on October 12.
- The money moved: Rs 56.75 lakh is in the Sahyadri Tiger Reserve account; the original 4% demand of Rs 227 crore has not been collected.
- The company’s line: Rs 56.75 crore was survey and investigation cost on the wildlife portal, about 1% of the plant, while the state wildlife board considered Rs 5,675 crore.
WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED
- Who checked the affidavit: No public note yet shows an audited estimate, a comparison with the clearance, or a legal opinion before the October 12 acceptance.
- What the national board will use: Whether it will see Rs 5,675 crore, Rs 56.75 crore, or a survey-only filing has not been decided, because the standing committee has not heard the case.
- What the state probe will do with the Rs 56.75 lakh: Whether that deposit is treated as 1% of a survey budget or 1% of a restated plant, and whether Rs 227 crore is restored, is still open.
The Sahyadri tiger reserve conservation fee Adani Satara fight will not be settled by another press statement. It will be settled when the state inquiry says whether “project cost” on a wildlife file is allowed to mean a survey line that is 1% of the plant the environment ministry already cleared, and when the National Board for Wildlife, if it takes the case, picks a denominator of its own. Until then the reserve holds Rs 56.75 lakh on a plant whose clearance still reads Rs 5,675 crore.
NEWS2 months agoClancy Juror Says the Holdout Never Cited Evidence
NEWS3 months agoThe iPhone 18 Pro Max Splits Apple’s Fall in Two
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Calls GPT-6 Astra AGI Then Locks Its Exploits
BUSINESS3 months agoTrump Claims Hormuz Control as Oil Holds Near $96
LIFESTYLE3 months agoRussia Closes the Goethe-Institut Berlin Tried to Save
AUTO3 months agoVolkswagen’s Job Cuts Leave Four Plants Without Cars
NEWS3 months agoDyson Puts Nurovi Robots on Sale Without the UV Flagship
BUSINESS2 months agoUS Destroys Five Iranian Tankers as the Shock Hits Jordan













