ENTERTAINMENT
Powell Finds the Rape Myths She Thought Had Left Court
After Russell Brand’s 10 years and six months term, Lucy Powell said courts had moved on. His defence still used rape myths her government has yet to bind.
Lucy Powell called the cross-examination of Russell Brand’s victims depressing after he was jailed for 10 years and six months. The Labour deputy leader, who is also education secretary, told LBC she thought the courts had “long gone past that sort of culture.”
His barrister, Ian Winter KC, had suggested Brand must be innocent because none of the women had “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave.” That line is still a working defence in 2026, which is why peers spent the afternoon of the sentence arguing over whether judges must warn juries about it before a word of evidence is heard.
Lucy Powell Thought the Courts Had Moved On
Powell was asked on LBC whether Winter’s case sounded like the 1950s. She said she had been shocked by some of what took place in the courtroom, while praising the judge. “I found reading some of that incredibly sort of depressing,” she said. “I thought we’d long gone past that sort of culture and that phase of things.”
She pointed to the sentencing, where Mr Justice Bennathan told Brand that clothing, conduct and drink do not cancel the right to refuse sex. “And if it’s not given, then that is rape and that is a sexual offence, pure and simple,” Powell said.
The government, she added, has already put guidance out to challenge rape myths and victim-blaming in court. “But clearly, a lot more needs to be done because I think many of us were really shocked that that could still take place in a courtroom today.”
The shock is the political line. The record is colder. Winter’s questions were asked in open court, the jury still had to sit through them, and the law that is supposed to box those myths in is still, in the part that covers jury directions, a matter of judicial choice.

A Short and Momentary Failure
Brand, 51, was convicted on Thursday 5 November 2026 of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault against four women between 2004 and 2009. He was cleared of two further counts of rape and one of attempted indecent assault. He had denied all of the charges.
Winter’s trial case leaned on the old tests of how a “real” victim behaves. At sentence on Monday 9 November, the mitigation went further. He told Southwark Crown Court the rape should be treated as a short, momentary failure to respect consent already given, in two respects: a limit to vaginal sex, and a condom kept on. He said there had been no planning. The judge cut in to note that nobody had claimed the rape was planned.
WHAT THE DEFENCE TOLD THE COURT
- The scream test: Winter suggested Brand must be innocent because none of the women had resisted, screamed, or even tried to leave.
- The delay: He treated the fact that they had not come forward during the 2017 MeToo wave as a hit on their credibility.
- The rape: He called the attack on a 21-year-old fan in spring 2009 a short, momentary failure by a man who “went too far and overrode consent that had been given.”
- The bar: Of a woman whose breasts Brand groped in Soho in 2004, he said she was “not particularly vulnerable at all,” and that being tipsy did not make her so.
He also called the four crimes isolated incidents, and said the last of them came shortly before Brand met his first wife, Katy Perry. In written submissions he argued that forcing the rape victim to shower and brush her teeth was “not entirely surprising” in a man who is an ex-alcoholic. He asked the judge to show mercy for Laura Brand and their three children, including a child who had just turned 10, and said Brand is “a fundamentally different person today.”
Bennathan’s sentencing remarks at Southwark Crown Court answered that pitch in public. He called Brand a sexual predator whose fame protected him until 2023, when reporting by The Times, The Sunday Times and Channel 4’s Dispatches brought other women forward. He said Brand had told “a series of lies,” including a trial claim that he had never touched a woman without her consent. He did not raise the sentence because of how the defence was run. He did say the extra suffering was done on Brand’s instructions.
Whatever women wear, wherever they go, whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice in the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Mr Brand, act without their consent.
Mr Justice Bennathan, Southwark Crown Court, 9 November 2026
On the rape count he found that the 21-year-old had agreed to one form of sex after a show and that Brand, then 33, stored her number under “T” for “tart.” Consent to that act was not consent to what followed. The judge said both the woman who went to a party and had a few drinks, and the woman who went to Brand’s house for one type of consensual sex, had taken “perfectly reasonable decisions,” and that those choices did not cut Brand’s blame.
How Russell Brand’s Sentence Breaks Down
Prosecutor Reil Karmy-Jones KC had asked for a category 1 term on the rape, a band that runs from 10 to 15 years, citing severe psychological harm and degrading treatment. Winter pushed for a band between category 2 and 3. Category 2 has a starting point of eight years and a range of seven to nine. The judge imposed nine years on the rape, then added assault terms that run with each other but after the rape.
HOW THE TERM WAS BUILT
| Count | Offence | Term | Setting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rape | Anal rape after consensual sex, condom removed | 9 years | Brand’s London home, spring 2009, 21-year-old fan |
| Sexual assault | Breasts grabbed | 9 months | Soho bar, 2004, birthday party |
| Sexual assault | Face grabbed, kiss, breasts and bottom touched | 18 months, cut from 2 years | Choice FM studios, 2004 or 2005 |
| Sexual assault | Head put in a colleague’s lap without consent | 8 months | Channel 4 filming project, 2009 |
| Total | Assaults concurrent, consecutive to the rape | 10 years and six months | At least two-thirds to be served before parole |
Three of the four crimes happened in front of other people, at a bar, a radio station and a film set. The women said others in the room laughed. The judge called that extra humiliation, and said the Channel 4 assault showed “staggering arrogance” and an entourage that “indulged your dreadful behaviour.” He treated 17 years with no further reported crimes as mitigation. He rejected an “abuse of trust” uplift in the guideline sense, because being famous is not that legal category, while agreeing that celebrity made the harm harder to escape.
The Metropolitan Police has passed files on complaints from two other women to the Crown Prosecution Service. That work is separate from the counts on which he was sentenced.
Peers Argued the Fix That Afternoon
By 3.18pm on the same Monday, the Lords were already treating the Brand court as a test of whether current practice is enough. Baroness Levitt, a Labour peer, asked a private notice question on mandatory jury directions in rape trials. She said reports from the trial had caused distress to victims, and that while most judges direct juries on harmful myths, the fact that some do not is why Parliament should require a direction before any evidence is heard, not only at the end, when the damage may already be done.
Lord Lemos, the justice minister answering, would not comment on the Brand case. He paid tribute to the women who gave evidence, then fell back on the existing toolkit: independent judges already can and do give myth directions case by case; the Judicial College’s Crown Court Compendium is the main guide; sexual-offence judges receive RASSO training. The Courts and Tribunals Bill, he said, will stop previous rape allegations and compensation claims being used unfairly. Baroness Levitt’s amendments, he added, would be considered the following week.
WHERE THE LORDS SPLIT
- Baroness Levitt: Make the myth direction mandatory, and give it before evidence starts, because guidance leaves gaps.
- Lord Burnett of Maldon: The former lord chief justice said the Court of Appeal has been pushing these directions for almost two decades, the Compendium is already detailed, and it would be unprecedented for Parliament to tell judges how to direct juries.
- Baroness Chakrabarti: Judicial independence still leaves room for Parliament to set rules, as it did when it banned rape defendants from cross-examining in person.
Lord Keen of Elie and Viscount Hailsham backed leaving directions to the trial judge. Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames, for the Liberal Democrats, used young people’s weaker grasp of consent as a reason for both clearer jury directions and better sex education. Baroness Sugg quoted the prime minister’s Friday line that “we need to do more to support victims of sexual assault and rape,” and asked for concrete steps. Lemos listed independent legal advisers for adult rape victims in 2026, with £6 million over two years, specialist rape and serious sexual offence courts backed by £23 million, and a new rape justice taskforce chaired by the lord chancellor.
That is not a government that thinks the culture has already gone. It is a government arguing, on the afternoon of a celebrity rape sentence, about how far the statute book should go in tying judges’ hands.
What Ministers Were Told a Year Ago
Powell’s “a lot more needs to be done” lands on a pile of paper that was already there. The Law Commission report on sexual offence trials, published on 22 July 2025, said rape myths still seep into the process and into jurors’ deliberations. It defined those myths as sincere beliefs about sexual violence that are factually wrong and drawn from stereotypes. Among the fixes: tighter rules on sexual-behaviour evidence, therapy records and compensation claims; independent legal advice for complainants on those applications; mandatory training for all lawyers; stronger jury directions; and, in some complex trials, expert evidence on how people actually respond to sexual violence.
It kept juries for serious sexual offences, saying the evidence did not support taking them out. It wanted complainants to have a right to standard measures such as screens, video links and pre-recorded evidence, without having to justify the ask. Professor Penney Lewis, the criminal law commissioner, said the package was meant to stop myths distorting the trial while still letting a defendant put a proper case.
THE YEAR THE PAPERWORK MOVED
- 22 July 2025: The Law Commission publishes its final report on evidence in sexual offence prosecutions, including mandatory training and better jury directions on myths.
- 3 December 2025: Ministers announce a December package to limit rape myths, raising the bar on using previous allegations, sexual history and compensation claims, after a victims’ commissioner survey found that in 2024 nearly 60% of victims overall believed they could not get justice.
- 13 July 2026: The Early Victims’ Right to Review scheme, first piloted in the West Midlands in June 2025, is rolled out to every CPS area so rape complainants can seek a second prosecutor’s view before a case is dropped in court.
- 9 November 2026: Brand is sentenced; hours later the Lords open a live argument on whether myth directions should be mandatory.
David Lammy, then deputy prime minister, said on 3 December 2025 that far too many rape victims drop out because they feel they are the ones on trial. Alex Davies-Jones, the victims minister, said the least they can expect is not to be “made a spectacle of in the courtroom.” Katrin Hohl, the government’s independent adviser on criminal justice responses to sexual violence, welcomed a shift that puts the focus back on the defendant and the facts. None of that stopped Winter putting the scream test to a jury in 2026, because the Compendium still leaves the warning to the judge in the case.
The December package also sat beside £550 million for victims’ support services over three years. Specialist courts and early review of dropped cases deal with delay and with prosecutors who stop too soon. They do not, by themselves, police what a silk is allowed to say about a woman who did not shout.
The Kitchen Interview Labour Now Regrets
Powell spent Tuesday morning on a second front: the 15-minute interview Ed Miliband, then Labour leader, gave Brand in 2015 for the comedian’s YouTube show The Trews, filmed in Brand’s east London home. Powell was a senior figure on that campaign. Asked by Sophy Ridge whether she had set the interview up and whether she regretted it, she said it was a long time ago, and that if she, Miliband or anyone else had had “any sense at all that this was someone who was a sexual predator,” it would not have happened. “History would have been very, very different.”
She said Brand had approached the party, not the other way round. Then she added a line that will follow her: “We weren’t in the social media age at the time, where you could maybe search things up and see allegations about somebody at the time.” The interview was released on YouTube. Brand already had a large online audience. His book Revolution was the hook. Miliband’s public defence at the time was that some people found the campaign boring and that he wanted to reach voters who had switched off.
Powell also said she has “a very low threshold” for “power hungry, arrogant, rude, sexual-predating men,” and that what was known then is not what is known now. She grouped Labour with Hollywood and the BBC as institutions that gave Brand “a very, very powerful platform.” On the BBC side, a 2025 review of his time on Radio 2 and 6 Music in 2006 and 2007 looked at eight complaints and concerns, found only one had been made formally, and found that complaint had not been handled well. Several people told the review they had felt unable to speak up because of his status. Director-general Matt Brittin has now written to staff saying valid criticism has been aimed at media workplace culture, and that he wants concerns heard “at the highest level,” including in the next charter talks.
The 2015 tape is a political embarrassment. It is not why Winter could still ask why nobody screamed. That permission sits in the trial rules, not in a kitchen in Hackney.
Young Adults Still Fail the Fight-Back Test
The myth Winter used is not a 1950s antique. It is current, and it is worse among the age group that fills a large share of juries. Lord Marks put the figures on the record in the Lords. They come from a Crown Prosecution Service study, published with the End Violence Against Women Coalition, a survey of more than 3,000 adults.
WHAT THE 18 TO 24 GROUP GOT WRONG
- Fighting back: Only 53% of 18 to 24 year olds recognised that it can still be rape if a victim does not resist or fight back, against 74% of adults overall.
- Marriage: Only 42% of that age group recognised that being in a relationship or marriage does not mean consent to sex can be assumed, against 87% of people aged 65 and over.
- Reporting: Only 43% of 18 to 24 year olds recognised that victims may not go to the police at once.
Andrea Simon, then director of the coalition, called the slide among young people a “stark regression” and tied it to online misogyny. That is the pool a barrister is talking to when he asks why a woman did not scream. After Brand’s sentence, a loud strain of commentary treated the verdict as thin evidence and as a reason for men to avoid women in business and in private. That is the scream test with the volume turned up. Bennathan’s published remarks, which people began circulating in full once the PDF went up, describe four women, named offences, and a man the judge called a sexual predator. They are not a pamphlet about voting.
Powell is right that the questions in Brand’s trial sounded like a culture the political class had filed under finished. Winter was still allowed to ask them. Levitt’s amendment, due to be debated in the week beginning 16 November 2026, is the first vote that treats that gap as a drafting problem rather than a mood. Files on two further complaints are already with the CPS.
NEWS2 months agoClancy Juror Says the Holdout Never Cited Evidence
NEWS3 months agoThe iPhone 18 Pro Max Splits Apple’s Fall in Two
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Calls GPT-6 Astra AGI Then Locks Its Exploits
BUSINESS3 months agoTrump Claims Hormuz Control as Oil Holds Near $96
LIFESTYLE3 months agoRussia Closes the Goethe-Institut Berlin Tried to Save
AUTO3 months agoVolkswagen’s Job Cuts Leave Four Plants Without Cars
NEWS3 months agoDyson Puts Nurovi Robots on Sale Without the UV Flagship
BUSINESS2 months agoUS Destroys Five Iranian Tankers as the Shock Hits Jordan













