Connect with us

ENTERTAINMENT

The Court Asked for Volunteers, Then Had to Rescue One

BMC pulled Dia Mirza’s unpaid Deepavali clip after a BJP objection, and the High Court that wanted celebrity appeals ordered it back.

Published

on

The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation pulled actor Dia Mirza’s anti-firecracker Deepavali video on November 1 after BJP Mumbai president Ameet Satam objected. A Bombay High Court bench on November 3 told the civic body to put the clip back. By November 4 it had not returned to the same feeds.

Mirza recorded the appeal at BMC’s request and charged nothing. The video sat inside a campaign the court itself had asked for. The civic body then cut one face, kept the others, and left the street ban in place.

BMC Took the Clip Down the Same Night

A civic official said BMC posted Mirza’s appeal on its official X account at 8.25 a.m. on November 1 and removed it later that night. The caption said that, under Bombay High Court orders, bursting firecrackers on public roads, lanes and footpaths was strictly prohibited, and that Mirza had asked citizens not to burst them and to avoid noise.

Satam, who is also the Andheri West MLA, tagged the civic handle and wrote, “We don’t need lessons on how to celebrate #Diwali from @deespeak. Our traditions are deeply rooted in our culture.” The clip came down within hours. BMC issued no public note on why only that face disappeared.

THE WEEK THE CLIP WENT UP AND CAME DOWN

  1. September 21, 2026: Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale open Suo Motu PIL No. 1 of 2026 on festival noise, amplifiers and firecrackers on public streets.
  2. September 22, 2026: The bench imposes a total ban on bursting firecrackers on public streets and roads during festivities.
  3. October 15, 2026: The same bench says that order runs through the year and across every festival, not only Ganeshotsav.
  4. October 26, 2026: The judges tell the state not to spend public money on celebrity awareness films and to invite stars who will work unpaid.
  5. November 1, 2026: BMC posts Mirza’s clip at 8.25 a.m. and takes it down that night after Satam objects.
  6. November 3, 2026: The same bench asks BMC to re-upload the clip. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis calls the row a small issue.
  7. November 4, 2026: Mirza’s video has not returned to the civic handles that still carry the other celebrity appeals.

Municipal Commissioner Ashwini Bhide runs the administration that posted the campaign and then pulled one of its films. On November 3 the judges told BMC’s counsel to congratulate her for getting celebrities to speak. The takedown had already happened under the same roof.

The Bench Had Already Asked for Volunteers

The clip did not wander onto a civic feed. In October, additional government pleader Jyoti Chavan told the bench that some film personalities wanted fees to join the anti-pollution drive. Justice Kulkarni cut that off. Public money, he said, should not to pay celebrities for awareness films.

“Don’t go to any celebrity who is going to charge you,” the bench said. “If celebrities are not conscious about their own city, and they want to come only at fees, we are very sorry.” The judges said they had assumed people with a stake in Mumbai would give 15 minutes back.

Mirza did that. Officials said BMC approached her, and she recorded and sent the appeal at no cost. She is the UN Environment Programme’s Goodwill Ambassador for India. In her own post after the takedown she wrote, “Koi paise nahi liye hain. Bhalai ka zamana hee nahi raha.”

State counsel later told the bench that the October order had created so much goodwill that some celebrities came forward on their own. Mirza was the one who then needed the court’s protection. The volunteer rule, written to keep the campaign clean of invoices, produced a fight over who is allowed to speak at a Hindu festival.

Who Stayed Online After the Takedown

BMC had asked several public figures to record the same civic line: skip firecrackers, cut noise, keep the air breathable. After Satam’s post, only Mirza’s film vanished from the civic X and Instagram accounts. The others stayed.

THE CAMPAIGN FACES BMC KEPT AND CUT

PersonPublic roleClip on BMC feeds after Nov. 1
Dia MirzaActor, UNEP Goodwill Ambassador for IndiaTaken down the night of November 1
Madhuri DixitActorLeft up
Nishigandha WadActorLeft up
Ajinkya RahaneCricketerLeft up

The split is the tell. The civic line did not change. The messenger did. Satam, asked why he had not objected to the other names, said they stood for arts and sports; he tied Mirza to “anti-India forces.” Mayor Ritu Tawde backed the deletion and called the actor “anti-Hindu,” adding that the city had “blacklisted her.”

Deputy Mayor Sanjay Ghadi, from alliance partner Shiv Sena, did not follow that line. He said he found nothing wrong in Mirza’s appeal and questioned why it had to come down. Shiv Sena spokesperson Shaina NC took the other side and said Mumbai did not need lessons from the actor on Deepavali.

Satam Objected and the Mayor Called Her Anti-Hindu

In the film, Mirza said, “While celebrating Diwali, we should take care of the environment and our health. Pollution caused by firecrackers is harmful to all of us.” She closed, “Celebrate Diwali not with noise but happiness.” That is the script BMC asked her to record, and it is the script the court had already written into a street ban.

She later said Deepavali marks the triumph of light over darkness, knowledge over ignorance, and hope over despair, and that the clip was made for public awareness. “Why would anyone be critical of a video the Honourable Bombay High Court and the BMC have made me record in public interest?” she asked. “Air pollution is an area of concern, and all efforts to reduce pollution should be welcomed because it’s a matter of public health.”

WHAT THE OBJECTORS SAID

  • Ameet Satam: Hindus did not need lessons from Mirza on how to celebrate Deepavali, and the traditions were “deeply rooted in our culture.”
  • Ritu Tawde: The mayor called Mirza “anti-Hindu,” said she sided with “divisive forces,” and cited old fights over the Narmada dam, the uniform civil code, and a comment on the NEET exam.
  • Nitesh Rane: The Maharashtra minister asked why she had not made similar appeals at Eid, Muharram or Bakri Eid, and said people like her were “against the Sanatan Hindu religion.”
  • Sanjay Shirsat: The social justice minister said she should also make a video about noise from loudspeakers, a line aimed at mosques.

The judges heard that chorus inside a pollution case, not a fresh suit. They said Mirza had acted on their own directions, that her message on air and noise was “really good,” and that the remarks that followed were “really unfortunate.” Justice Gokhale called it a pure environment issue. “Everyone is breathing the same air, be it anyone,” she said. “It’s not that barring firecrackers is taking away your right to celebrate the festival.”

A festival is for everyone to celebrate. No individual can be isolated from celebrating any festival in this country. How can you object to someone’s participation just because that person is from some other religion? Aren’t we a secular country.

Justices Girish Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale, oral remarks, Bombay High Court, November 3, 2026

The bench said it was “disturbed by the stray comments made by some politicians,” spoke of a “petty mindset” among some elected representatives, and said there was “no room for factionalism” when the subject was health and air. “We have not seen any politician or any person who made remarks yesterday put up videos spreading awareness,” the judges said. “We are a secular country. We are really hurt by this.”

They told BMC to re-upload the clip and “restore the confidence of the people,” and said there was no need for a “knee-jerk reaction.” Mumbai, they said, “survives on togetherness and strong feeling of belongingness,” and “this balance ought not to be disturbed by any loose comment.” They also said the commissioner had been “absolutely correct” in the choice of celebrities, and that no one could question why a particular name had been picked.

The Street Ban Covers Every Festival

The fight over the film sits on top of an order that already binds the city. On October 15 the bench made a year-round ban on firecrackers on public streets, lanes and footpaths, and a complete restraint in silence zones around hospitals, government offices, courts and schools. The September 22 order, the judges said, was never only a Ganpati rule.

“There cannot be any distinction between different festivities taking place throughout the year,” the bench wrote. Any reading that confined the ban to one season was “wholly untenable.” BMC and the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board were told to publish notices that burning firecrackers at public places would not be permitted. On November 3 the judges repeated that the firecracker controls run “all 365 days,” not only Deepavali.

A civic official, after the takedown, said the corporation’s stand on bursting crackers had not moved, because it was still following the High Court. The film could vanish. The prohibition on roads, lanes and footpaths could not. That is the odd result of the week: the legal rule stayed, and the unpaid appeal meant to explain it was treated as the problem.

The same festival week, the Supreme Court set timed green-cracker windows for Delhi-NCR. Mumbai’s argument is narrower and sharper. The High Court has already barred bursting on public streets. The quarrel is over who may say so on a civic channel.

Fadnavis Calls the Row a Small Issue

In Pune on November 3, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis declined to treat the deletion as a matter for his desk. “This is a very small issue,” he told reporters. “I believe the high court may have expressed its opinion, but the matter has not even gone to the high court.” The bench had taken the controversy on its own motion inside the pollution PIL already before it.

He also framed the takedown as a social-media choice. “Deleting the video was the Mumbai Municipal Corporation’s decision. The authority that manages the social media handle has the right to decide what content should be retained and what should be removed,” he said. “Dia Mirza may be a good actress, but she is not a very big leader of India. Therefore, I feel this is not an issue of my level.”

That answer sits next to the bench’s language about the Constitution, secular spirit, and public confidence. It also sits next to the speed of November 1. A party president posted. The clip came down the same night. A High Court bench asked for it back two days later. The person who actually runs Maharashtra called the whole thing small and left it with the handle owner.

BMC is a civic body under a BJP mayor, and it is also the agency the court keeps ordering to print notices, run school drives, and put celebrities on camera. When those two pressures collide, the film is what moves. The street ban is what is supposed to stay. The people who have to police both, ward by ward, are the ones left holding a campaign that now needs political clearance before it can speak.

The Restored Video Has Not Appeared

On November 4, Madhuri Dixit’s appeal, Nishigandha Wad’s appeal and Ajinkya Rahane’s appeal were still on BMC’s X and Instagram. Mirza’s was not. The court had called a re-upload the way to restore confidence. The civic feeds had not done it.

Deepavali falls on November 8. The ban on bursting firecrackers on Mumbai’s public streets, lanes and footpaths is already the law, with or without her face on the civic account. The unpaid volunteer the bench wanted is still the one clip that is missing.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending