Connect with us

NEWS

Centre Tells the Court the Air India Probe Is Ending

India told the Supreme Court the AI171 crash inquiry is nearly done after missing its own October deadline for the draft.

Published

on

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the Supreme Court on 18 November 2026 that the Air India crash investigation is at its fag end. He asked a bench led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant for two to three more weeks, saying the investigators had to follow international protocols. Flight AI171, a Boeing 787-8 registered VT-ANB, went down shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad for London Gatwick on 12 June 2025. The UK accident branch, still attached to the Indian inquiry as an Annex 13 expert, puts the toll at 260 people on the aircraft and on the ground.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing on the petition by the captain’s father, told the bench the final report still had not been made public. The court listed the matter after two weeks. That listing lands before any public cause of the crash, not after it.

Centre Told the Court the Probe Is Nearly Finished

Mehta’s line was meant to keep the court from ordering a second inquiry while the official one is still open. Pushkar Raj Sabharwal, father of Captain Sumeet Sabharwal, and the Federation of Indian Pilots asked in October 2025 for a judicially monitored committee headed by a retired Supreme Court judge. They want the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau file closed and the evidence moved.

We are at the fag end of the investigation.

Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India, Supreme Court, 18 November 2026

He also said there was no reason to delay the work on purpose. The same government had already told this court, in July 2026, that a draft final report would be ready around the first week of October 2026 and could even be filed in a sealed cover. That week came and went. Bhushan used the missed date to press for an early listing. Mehta answered with protocol.

The two clocks in the courtroom are not the same. Mehta asked for two to three weeks to finish a draft. The bench put the petitions two weeks out, around 2 December 2026. A draft is not a published finding. Under the rules the Centre is citing, other countries still get a look before India posts a cause.

What the July 2025 Report Already Put on Record

AAIB’s 12 July 2025 preliminary report did not name a probable cause. It did lock in a sequence that has framed every hearing since. Of the 242 people on board, 241 were killed. Nineteen people died on the ground at the BJ Medical College hostel. One person on the aircraft survived.

The 787 left the runway at 08:08:39 UTC. Three seconds later both engine fuel cutoff switches moved from RUN to CUTOFF, one second apart. Fuel on board was 54,200 kg. Take-off weight was 213,401 kg, under the 218,183 kg limit.

THE CUTOFF SEQUENCE ON AI171

EventTime (UTC)
Lift-off08:08:39
Peak 180 kt; both fuel switches to CUTOFF08:08:42
Engine 1 switch back to RUNabout 08:08:52
Engine 2 switch back to RUNa few seconds later

The report recorded a cockpit exchange it did not assign to either man. One pilot asked the other why he had cut off the fuel. The other said he had not. First Officer Clive Kunder, 32, had 3,403 hours. The captain was Sumeet Sabharwal. Investigators did not say who spoke which line, and they did not say how the switches moved.

The switches have a lock that is supposed to stop a bump from cutting the engines. The same report pointed to a 2018 FAA special airworthiness bulletin on the risk that this lock can sit disengaged, a notice first raised on Boeing 737s and relevant to the 787 part fitted on VT-ANB. Air India had not done the inspection. The bulletin was advice, not an order. The throttle control module that houses the switches had been replaced in 2019 and in 2023, for reasons the report said were not tied to the fuel switches, and no fuel-switch defect had been logged on this aircraft since 2023.

About ten seconds after cutoff, the Engine 1 switch went back to RUN and that core began to recover. Engine 2 followed and relit, then failed to hold the recovery. The report issued no safety directive to 787 or GE GEnx operators. It also left the central question open: who or what moved the switches.

Other States See the Draft Before Families Do

That open question is now sitting inside a comment loop the public cannot enter. ICAO Annex 13 requires the state that runs the inquiry to send a draft Final Report for comments to a fixed list of other states. The usual window is 30 days from the transmittal letter. It stretches to 60 days if a recipient asks, and it can run longer if the states agree.

THE STATES THAT GET THE DRAFT

  • State of occurrence: India opened the inquiry because the aircraft came down at Ahmedabad.
  • State of registry and operator: India again, for VT-ANB and Air India.
  • State of design and manufacture: the United States, for a Boeing 787-8 with GE engines.
  • Other participants: any state that joined the inquiry, including the United Kingdom, which is still passing families only what India has cleared for release.

India, the United States and the United Kingdom can argue over wording before 260 families read a finding. If a comment is accepted, the draft changes. If it is not, the dissent can be appended. Either way, the first full narrative of this crash will have been through foreign capitals before it is through the Supreme Court record in public form.

The same annex wants a final report publicly available within twelve months. If that mark is missed, the investigating state is supposed to issue an anniversary update. 12 June 2026 was that mark. AAIB put out a June 12, 2026 interim statement instead of a cause. It said the team had gone through aircraft systems, recorder data, engine parts, maintenance files and operational records, with accredited representatives and technical advisers in support, and that more specialist tests would continue. The final report, it said, would wait until those tests and the international review were done.

The sole purpose of an accident investigation is to enhance aviation safety through the identification of lessons and safety recommendations, and not to apportion blame or liability.

Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau, interim statement, 12 June 2026

The bureau asked the press and the public not to guess. The petition in front of the Chief Justice exists because the captain’s father says the guessing already happened, in his house, in official language.

Pushkar Raj Sabharwal Versus a Closed Draft

Sabharwal was 91 when he and the Federation of Indian Pilots, a body of more than 6,000 pilots, filed on 10 October 2025. He says two AAIB officials who visited him implied that his son had cut the fuel after take-off. The government has called the inquiry clean and thorough. The petition says the five-member team is packed with Directorate General of Civil Aviation officers, so the regulator is looking at itself, and that Boeing and GE people in the room undercut the claim of distance.

On 7 November 2025 a bench of Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi issued notices to the Centre, DGCA and AAIB. The judges told the father not to carry the burden on himself and said the first report did not insinuate anything against the pilot. That comfort did not close the case. It also did not travel cleanly outside the courtroom. A compressed version of the exchange went around as a full clearing of the captain, complete with lines the bench is not shown to have used. The file on 18 November 2026 was still a closed draft and a live petition, not a verdict.

AAIB has told the court it prepared a cockpit-voice transcript and ran a psychological autopsy, a human-factors tool that sits uncomfortably next to the bureau’s own line about not apportioning blame. It has also told the court there is a statutory bar, under the Aircraft (Investigation of Accidents and Incidents) Rules, on handing cockpit voice and airborne image recordings to an outside committee. A parallel probe the father wants would, on the government’s reading, be built without the tape that made the first report famous.

WHERE EXPERTS DISAGREE

  • The Centre and AAIB: the inquiry is lawful, internationally supervised, and close enough that a court-monitored replacement is unnecessary.
  • Sabharwal and the pilots’ federation: the first report steered the story toward the crew, left design and oversight half-examined, and cannot sit in judgment of the offices that staffed it.
  • The hardware dispute: lock-detent tests in Seattle found no fault, while the full thrust module and engine-management work were still running, so the switch is not a closed mechanical chapter.

In September 2026 the federation wrote to Civil Aviation Minister K. Ram Mohan Naidu asking that its technical notes be read before AAIB froze the draft. The court had already said the federation could send inputs to the bureau. Sending notes into a file you are also trying to replace is the bind the 18 November 2026 adjournment leaves in place.

Seattle Tests Cleared the Switch Lock

By late July 2026 the political line on the switches had hardened even as the metal was still overseas. Minister of State for Civil Aviation Murlidhar Mohol told the Rajya Sabha, in a written reply to Congress MP Jebi Mather Hisham, that DGCA had sent the fuel-control-switch locking mechanism for maker-level tests in Seattle. A close look at the switch, including the locking detents, found no abnormality, he said. Inspection of the complete thrust control module was still under way at the maker’s plant. All probable causes were still being examined, and the final report would go on the AAIB website when the work was done. He rejected the charge that the bureau was late.

That split matters for the father’s case. A clean detent test is not a clean module, and a clean module would still not explain two guarded switches moving one second apart after lift-off, then moving back. The first report had already said accidental movement should be hard. Parliament was told the lock was sound. The box that holds the lock was, at that date, still in Seattle. Engine-monitoring-unit data and organisational factors were, in the July 2026 affidavit, among the last items on the list. Engine tests had been run in April 2026, with further work on the engine management unit including a visit to France.

The anniversary delay was explained in those terms, as unfinished engine analysis, not as a quarrel about the crew. The petition treats that order of work as the problem. If the human-factors chapter, including a psychological autopsy, ran early, and the maker’s box was still open in Seattle in July, the first public story had a crew-shaped hole in it long before the metal was done talking.

Four Simulations Did Not Close the File

The court has been given dates before. They have not produced a public report. They have produced more dates.

THE DATES THE COURT WAS GIVEN

  1. 12 June 2025: AI171 strikes the medical college hostel after take-off from Ahmedabad.
  2. 12 July 2025: AAIB issues the factual first report on the fuel switches and the unassigned cockpit lines.
  3. 10 October 2025: Sabharwal and the Federation of Indian Pilots ask the Supreme Court to replace the bureau with a judge-led committee.
  4. 7 November 2025: notices issue; the bench tells the father the first report does not insinuate guilt.
  5. 12 June 2026: the twelve-month mark; AAIB issues an interim update, not a cause.
  6. July 2026: AAIB tells the court a draft should be ready around October after remaining engine-monitoring and organisational work, and that a court-monitored probe is not required.
  7. 28 July 2026: Mehta says four simulation tests have been run and that a draft can be filed in a sealed cover in the first week of October; the bench lists 13 October 2026.
  8. 18 November 2026: Mehta says the inquiry is at its fag end and asks for two to three weeks; the petitions come back after two weeks.

Four simulations were already complete in July. A sealed cover was already on offer in July. The October 13 listing did not put a cause on the website. Minister Ram Mohan Naidu had told the Rajya Sabha in March 2026 that the final report was expected within the year. With six weeks left in 2026, the government is now selling a draft, then a comment period, then a posting.

The Public File Still Waits on Foreign Comments

If AAIB does hand a draft around in two to three weeks, Annex 13 still sits in front of the families. Thirty days is the ordinary wait. Sixty days is the wait if Washington or another recipient asks. The Supreme Court will already have sat again, around 2 December 2026, while that clock is running. Mehta’s “fag end” and Bhushan’s unread report can both be true in the same fortnight, because the end of the Indian drafting is not the start of public reading.

The captain’s father came to court to stop a closed process from becoming the last word on his son. The government’s answer is that the process is so close to a last word that the court should not touch it. Other states will read the draft first. The tape that made the first report famous is, on the bureau’s own legal reading, not for an outside committee. The lock on the switches was cleared in Seattle while the module that holds them was still there. Two weeks is another listing. It is not a finding.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending