BUSINESS
Bombay High Court Puts Kochhar’s Trial Behind an RBI Gate
The Bombay High Court quashed ICICI Bank’s sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar, shifting the corruption-trial gate for private-bank chiefs to the RBI.
The Bombay High Court on November 18 quashed ICICI Bank’s sanction to prosecute former CEO Chanda Kochhar under the Prevention of Corruption Act. Justice Milind N. Jadhav held that only the Reserve Bank of India, not the bank’s board, was the competent authority.
The 57-page order set aside the May 15, 2023 sanction and the cognizance taken on it in CBI Special Case No. 874 of 2023. It also parked that gate at a regulator that never removed Kochhar and never recorded reasons.
A 57-Page Order and a Missing Signature
Kochhar had asked the High Court to strike down the board’s nod before charges were framed. Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh, appearing for the CBI, argued that the petition was not maintainable, that the board was competent under the Companies Act and the bank’s articles, and that any defect in sanction was a question for trial.
Justice Jadhav disagreed on all three points. He held that a writ court can test sanction at the threshold when the defect is the absence of a competent authority, which goes to jurisdiction, and that Section 36-AA of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, vests the power to remove a bank chairman, director or chief executive in the RBI alone.
Thus the power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only. Thus, there is no sanction order passed by the Competent Authority which is the RBI. No reasons are given by the RBI for removal of the Petitioner for that matter for issuing sanction order.
Justice Milind N. Jadhav, Bombay High Court
The judge said a sanction granted by an incompetent authority is a nullity, standing “on the same pedestal as an absent sanction,” and that cognizance taken on it is illegal. He quashed the May 15, 2023 document and the consequential actions of the special court, and he declined the CBI’s oral request for an eight-week stay to challenge the judgment.

RBI Never Issued a Removal Order
Kochhar became managing director and CEO of ICICI Bank on May 1, 2009. A 2014 ICICI Bank filing shows the RBI approved her re-appointment in that role up to April 30, 2017. She resigned in October 2018. On January 30, 2019, after a board enquiry headed by retired Supreme Court judge B.N. Srikrishna, the bank treated that exit as termination for cause and moved to claw back bonuses paid from April 2009 to March 2018.
That was not an RBI removal. Justice Jadhav recorded that the regulator passed no order against her, recorded no reasons, and never gave her the statutory chance to make a representation. Under the Banking Regulation Act, those steps are not optional paperwork. They are the process that has to exist before the person who can actually take a bank CEO out of office acts.
The court’s reading of the power to remove bank officers is what then decided the corruption case. Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act asks who can remove the public servant. If that person is the RBI, a board resolution cannot fill the gap.
WHAT SECTION 36AA REQUIRES
- Written reasons: The RBI may remove a chairman, director, chief executive or other officer only after recording reasons in writing, and only in public interest, to protect depositors, or to secure proper management.
- A hearing: No removal order can be made unless the person has had a reasonable opportunity to make a representation to the RBI against the proposed order, subject to an urgent interim bar.
- An appeal: The person may appeal to the Central Government within 30 days of the order being communicated, and the government’s decision is final.
- A management bar: The RBI may also keep the person out of the management of any banking company for a period not exceeding five years.
Justice Jadhav noted that if such an order had been required, Kochhar’s right to be heard by the RBI had been lost altogether. The CBI never asked the regulator to start that process. It wrote to the bank instead.
Who Can Sanction Prosecution of a Private Bank CEO?
Under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, a court cannot take cognizance of listed corruption offences without prior sanction from the authority that can remove the public servant. For ICICI Bank’s former managing director, Justice Jadhav held that authority is the RBI, not the bank’s board. The CBI had placed her in the residual clause, Section 19(1)(c), which covers “any other person.”
That clause does not name a minister or a secretary. It names whoever, in law, can take the officer out of the post. The CBI pointed to the Companies Act and to Clause 151(a) of ICICI Bank’s articles. The court said those sources cannot prevail, because Sections 5-A, 35-B, 36-AA and 36-AC of the Banking Regulation Act override conflicting company law and the bank’s own constitution. K. Veeraswami v. Union of India, the judge recalled, treats “authority competent to remove” as the authority without whose order the public servant cannot be removed.
SECTION 19’S THREE SANCTION GATES
| Clause | Who it covers | Who must sign |
|---|---|---|
| Section 19(1)(a) | A person employed in connection with the affairs of the Union, removable only by or with the sanction of the Central Government | The Central Government |
| Section 19(1)(b) | A person employed in connection with the affairs of a State, removable only by or with the sanction of the State Government | The State Government |
| Section 19(1)(c) | Any other public servant | The authority competent to remove that person from office |
The previous sanction necessary for prosecution is the lock on those listed offences. Justice Jadhav held that the ICICI Bank board, “a body constituted under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 whose power is specifically overruled by the provisions of the BR Act,” could not turn that key. He also held that Kochhar could still face an internal bank enquiry under the bank’s own rules. The anti-corruption trial was a different thing, because it needed the removing authority’s signature.
Allegations Without an Ounce of Evidence
The competence finding would have been enough. The judge added a second, independent ground. He found that the board never applied its mind to the CBI’s record.
The CBI wrote to ICICI Bank on March 27, 2023, seeking sanction. The board resolved to grant it on April 22, 2023, and issued the sanction on May 15, 2023. Justice Jadhav said the minutes and the sanction letter recorded the CBI’s letter and report, offered no reasons, and did not discuss witness statements or documents. The CBI’s underlying material, he held, was not placed before the board.
There is not an ounce of evidence to show that the sanctioning authority considered any material collected by the CBI, if any, in its investigation of Petitioner. There is not a whisper of any discussion on the evidence against Petitioner, if any, neither in the Minutes of Meeting of Board of Directors nor in the sanction granted therefrom, instead a mere conjecture and allegation is stated therein which cannot form a reasonable basis to prosecute the Petitioner even otherwise.
Justice Milind N. Jadhav, Bombay High Court
The same papers, the court said, recorded the bank’s own position that it had suffered no financial loss and that its lending policies had not been violated. The CBI had claimed the transactions caused wrongful loss of Rs 1,033.39 crore to ICICI Bank, a figure Kochhar disputed. Justice Jadhav said the agency could not “approbate and reprobate” at the same time. “Once it is the case of the Bank itself that there was no financial loss whatsoever caused to the bank, then in the background of such a stance adopted by the Bank, the indictment of the Petitioner cannot be sustained,” he held.
The CBI’s case, as recited in the proceedings, alleged that between June 2009 and October 2011 Kochhar sanctioned loans aggregating Rs 1,875 crore to Videocon Group companies despite her husband’s dealings with promoter Venugopal Dhoot. After a Rs 300 crore loan to Videocon International Electronics Ltd, the agency alleged, Rs 64 crore moved to NuPower Renewables Ltd, a company in which Deepak Kochhar was a director. The court noted that Kochhar was not the sole member of the committee that approved the two loans at issue, and that the bank’s records showed its policies had not been broken.
Those are the CBI’s allegations, still untested at trial. The High Court did not decide whether they are true. It decided that the paper which let a special court look at them under the Prevention of Corruption Act was not a valid sanction.
How a 2019 FIR Reached a Void Sanction
The CBI registered its FIR in January 2019, arrested Kochhar in December 2022, and asked ICICI Bank for sanction only on March 27, 2023. It filed a chargesheet the next day, before the board had even met. The special court took cognizance on July 12, 2023, after the May 15, 2023 sanction existed. That sequence is now the hole through which the PC Act case has fallen.
FROM THE FIR TO THE VOID SANCTION
- January 2019: The CBI registers an FIR under the Indian Penal Code and Sections 7, 13(1)(d) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act over Videocon Group loans.
- January 30, 2019: ICICI Bank’s board, after the Srikrishna enquiry, treats Kochhar’s October 2018 resignation as termination for cause and seeks clawback of bonuses paid from April 2009 to March 2018.
- February 2021: Kochhar is arrested in the Prevention of Money Laundering Act case.
- December 23, 2022: The CBI arrests Chanda Kochhar and Deepak Kochhar. The High Court grants interim bail on January 9, 2023, and in February 2024 holds the arrests illegal.
- March 27, 2023: The CBI writes to ICICI Bank seeking sanction under Section 19. The chargesheet is filed the next day, March 28, 2023.
- April 22, 2023: The board resolves to grant sanction. The sanction document is issued on May 15, 2023. The special court takes cognizance on July 12, 2023.
- December 4, 2023: Kochhar files the writ petition, before charge is framed. On November 18, 2026, the High Court allows it and refuses an eight-week stay.
Senior Advocate Abad Ponda appeared for Kochhar. The CBI had wanted the competence objection pushed into the trial. Justice Jadhav said forcing a public servant through a criminal trial on a sanction that was void from the start would defeat Section 19’s protection. The special court, he added, should not have taken cognizance mechanically without asking whether the authority that signed was competent in law.
Private Bank Chiefs Now Need a Regulator’s Signature
The PC Act reaches a private-bank managing director only because Indian law already treats that person as a public servant. In CBI v. Ramesh Gelli, decided on February 23, 2016, the Supreme Court held that the chairman, managing director and executive director of a private bank licensed by the RBI fall within the Act, reading it with Section 46A of the Banking Regulation Act. That is why a private-bank CEO needs sanction at all, and why the identity of the removing authority now decides whether a corruption trial can start.
Justice Jadhav’s answer, that the removing authority is the RBI, does not stay inside one chargesheet. Every future CBI request to prosecute a sitting or former private-bank chief under the listed PC Act offences will have to find a regulator willing to play that role, record reasons, and, if removal is in play, offer a hearing. The RBI has the private bank directors as public servants holding in its background. It has not, in this scandal, built the sanction file the High Court says the statute requires.
That reading is not uncontested. K.B.S. Sidhu, a retired Indian Administrative Service officer and former special chief secretary of Punjab, wrote that for a private-sector bank the board would ordinarily be the removing authority, and that prior RBI approval under Section 35-B for appointing or terminating a managing director “does not, by itself, convert the RBI into the appointing or removing authority.” “Regulatory approval and substantive authority to remove are legally distinct concepts,” he wrote. He added that if the RBI is held to be the competent authority, it can still grant or refuse sanction on the merits after examining the material.
WHERE EXPERTS DISAGREE
- The High Court: Sections 35-B and 36-AA, read with the override clauses of the Banking Regulation Act, mean a private-bank managing director cannot be removed without the RBI, so only the RBI can grant Section 19 sanction.
- K.B.S. Sidhu: Section 35-B is a prior-approval rule, not a removal power, and importing the public-sector appointment model into a private bank confuses regulatory consent with the authority that actually hires and fires.
The CBI’s remaining paths on the PC Act limb are an appeal against Wednesday’s judgment, or a fresh request to the RBI. The High Court has already said a void sanction cannot be cured by anything done later. A new request would have to be a new decision by a different authority, with the record actually placed before it.
The Money-Laundering Case Follows a Separate Track
The November 18 order is confined to the Prevention of Corruption Act sanction and to what the special court did on the back of it. It does not close the money-laundering case, and it does not unwind the bank’s 2019 employment decision.
On July 3, 2025, the PMLA Appellate Tribunal, in FPA-PMLA-3802/DLI/2020, set aside an earlier adjudicating-authority order and held on a prima facie basis that Rs 64 crore routed to NuPower Renewables was proceeds of crime, upholding the Enforcement Directorate’s attachment. The Directorate’s provisional order dated January 10, 2020, had attached assets valued at about Rs 74.54 crore. On May 8, 2026, the Bombay High Court granted an interim stay of that attachment and barred the Directorate from taking possession, pending the Kochhars’ appeal.
THE THREE TRACKS AROUND KOCHHAR
| Track | Forum | Status |
|---|---|---|
| PC Act prosecution | CBI Special Case No. 874 of 2023 | May 15, 2023 sanction and cognizance set aside on November 18, 2026; eight-week stay refused |
| Money-laundering attachment | PMLA Appellate Tribunal, then Bombay High Court | Tribunal on July 3, 2025 held Rs 64 crore to be proceeds of crime; High Court on May 8, 2026 stayed the about Rs 74.54 crore attachment |
| Bank employment action | ICICI Bank board | January 30, 2019 termination for cause, with clawback of bonuses paid from April 2009 to March 2018; the bank said the enquiry report had no effect on its published financial statements |
The Srikrishna enquiry had concluded that Kochhar violated the bank’s code of conduct and its conflict-of-interest and disclosure rules, chiefly by how she handled recusal. That is an internal finding, not a criminal verdict. The tribunal’s July 2025 order is a prima facie attachment ruling, with a final view reserved for a trial court. The November 18 judgment is a jurisdictional ruling on who may open a PC Act trial.
The CBI asked for eight weeks to take the sanction order up. The High Court said no. The corruption file now sits with a regulator that, in this case, has issued no removal order and no sanction of its own.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and legal analysis of a High Court order and related proceedings. It is for information only and is not legal advice, nor an opinion on guilt or innocence. Readers who face a related investigation, sanction request or attachment should consult a qualified criminal or banking lawyer before acting. Figures, case statuses and court findings reflect the public record of the sources cited and can change on appeal, on a fresh sanction request, or in later orders.
NEWS2 months agoClancy Juror Says the Holdout Never Cited Evidence
NEWS3 months agoThe iPhone 18 Pro Max Splits Apple’s Fall in Two
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Calls GPT-6 Astra AGI Then Locks Its Exploits
BUSINESS3 months agoTrump Claims Hormuz Control as Oil Holds Near $96
LIFESTYLE3 months agoRussia Closes the Goethe-Institut Berlin Tried to Save
AUTO3 months agoVolkswagen’s Job Cuts Leave Four Plants Without Cars
NEWS3 months agoDyson Puts Nurovi Robots on Sale Without the UV Flagship
BUSINESS2 months agoUS Destroys Five Iranian Tankers as the Shock Hits Jordan













