Connect with us

NEWS

Eisenkot’s Bloc Names Kahana Speaker Without a Governing Majority

Eisenkot’s bloc nominated Matan Kahana for Knesset speaker with 67 signatures, even as a government still needs 13 Haredi seats the campaign promised to confront.

Published

on

Eisenkot’s bloc named Matan Kahana its Knesset speaker nominee on November 10 and forced a replacement vote for November 17. The request carried 67 signatures, including the Arab lists most of those same parties will not take into a cabinet. The Zionist anti-Netanyahu camp holds 48 of 120 seats.

A speaker can be elected with those 67 names. A government still cannot. That gap is the whole fight now sitting in the new Knesset.

The Bloc Has 67 Votes for a Speaker and 48 for a Government

The final official results of the October 27 election left no camp with the 61 seats a cabinet needs. Benjamin Netanyahu’s outgoing partners have 53. Gadi Eisenkot’s four Zionist lists have 48. The Joint List and Ra’am hold 19. United Torah Judaism and Shas, the Haredi parties inside Netanyahu’s column, hold 13, which is exactly the number Eisenkot needs if he will not govern with Arab factions.

The Central Elections Committee recorded a voter turnout of 77.9 percent among 7,331,981 registered voters, the highest in decades. Yashar took 21 seats on 913,629 votes. Likud stayed first with 27 seats and 1,167,591 votes. Neither figure moves the 61-seat line.

THE 26TH KNESSET BY CAMP

CampListsSeatsGap to 61
Netanyahu partnersLikud, Otzma Yehudit, United Torah Judaism, Shas, Religious Zionism-Zehut538 short
Eisenkot’s Zionist partnersYashar, B’Yachad, Democrats, Yisrael Beytenu4813 short
Arab listsJoint List, Ra’am19Would make 67 with Eisenkot
Haredi lists inside the 53United Torah Judaism 7, Shas 613Would make 61 with Eisenkot

President Isaac Herzog used the 67 figure once already. Factions totaling 67 incoming members recommended Eisenkot during consultations. Forty-six recommended Netanyahu. United Torah Judaism’s 7 members recommended no one. Herzog announced his choice on November 7 and handed Eisenkot the letter of appointment on November 8. The first window is 28 days, to December 6, with a possible 14-day extension to December 20.

The speaker request is the same arithmetic in a different file. Yashar submitted the 67 signatures on November 10, the day the 26th Knesset was sworn in. United Torah Judaism had already said it would not vote to replace the speaker before a government was formed, so those names are Eisenkot’s 48 plus the 19 from the Joint List and Ra’am. Amir Ohana of Likud, who still holds the chair, set the plenary vote for November 17 at 4 p.m.

Eisenkot Took the Gavel Away From Lapid

Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Liberman first backed Yair Lapid for speaker. Lapid is Bennett’s deputy in B’Yachad and was opposition leader in the outgoing house. Eisenkot refused to give the chair to anyone outside Yashar. He and Liberman closed that argument in a meeting on November 9, and the five party leaders put Kahana’s name out the next morning.

Eisenkot announced the slate himself. Kahana for speaker. Roi Folkman of Yashar for the Arrangements Committee. Liberman for the temporary Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. Liran Avisar Ben Horin of B’Yachad for the temporary Finance Committee. Committee lineups, he said, would go to the plenum on November 11, with special committees to be named later.

The intra-bloc trade is plain. Eisenkot, whose list has 21 seats, kept the gavel and the Arrangements gavel in Yashar. Liberman, with 7, took the security panel that will handle a draft law. Bennett’s list, with 12, took Finance. Lapid, the man Bennett and Liberman had wanted in the speaker’s chair, got none of the four posts.

Ohana did not hide his view of the early vote. He said the unusual request was meant to advance legislation that would give immense power to the attorney general. He also said he would not cling to the chair. “Despite my strong opposition to the intentions of the emerging coalition, I will act as I promised and respect the will of the majority of Knesset members,” he said, and he put November 17 on the calendar.

Who Is Matan Kahana?

Matan Kahana is a Yashar lawmaker, a former F-16 colonel, and the minister who ran religious services in the 2021-2022 Bennett-Lapid government. He sits fifth on Eisenkot’s list after joining the new party in September 2025. The bloc chose him after Eisenkot refused to hand the speaker’s chair to Lapid, and after days of bargaining over who would take the other Knesset posts.

The Knesset file lists him as born in Haifa on July 29, 1972, resident in Beit Gamliel, and a combatant in Sayeret Matkal from 1990 to January 1994. He then flew in the air force from 1995 to 2019 and left as a colonel. Bennett served in the same commando unit. Kahana entered the Knesset in 2019 on Bennett’s right-wing ticket, later sat with Benny Gantz’s National Unity list, and resigned that seat in 2025 to follow Eisenkot.

KAHANA’S PATH TO THE NOMINATION

  • The army years: Sayeret Matkal, then 24 years as an air force pilot, finishing as a colonel.
  • The first lists: New Right and Yamina with Bennett, then National Unity with Gantz after that government fell.
  • The ministry: Religious services minister in 2021-2022, where he opened kosher supervision, changed conversion procedures, and put women on religious councils.
  • The split: He left Gantz in 2025, took fifth place on Yashar, and won a seat in the 21-member caucus.

That ministry record is why Haredi negotiators have reason to bristle. Kahana spent a year shifting power away from the Chief Rabbinate on kashrut and conversion, and Haredi parties fought him for it. The same parties now hold the 13 seats that would take Eisenkot from 48 to 61. Putting Kahana in the speaker’s chair pleases Yashar. It does not sweeten a call to Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch.

The Speaker Bid Rests on Arab Signatures

Joint List and Ra’am members signed the request that named Kahana and asked Ohana to schedule a vote. Their 19 seats are what turn 48 into 67. Yair Golan’s Democrats have not joined the rest of the Zionist partners in ruling out Arab factions as government partners. Liberman has. Kahana has. On election night, October 28, Kahana repeated that there would be no government that relies on Arab parties.

That line sits beside an older one. In June 2022, while deputy religious affairs minister in a government that already depended on Ra’am, Kahana spoke to high school students in Efrat. A recording of the talk spread the next day.

If there were a button you could press that would make all the Arabs disappear, that would send them on an express train to Switzerland, I would press that button.

Matan Kahana, then deputy religious affairs minister, to students in Efrat, June 2022

He added that no such button exists and that the two peoples were destined to live on the land in some form. He later said a few of his statements were worded poorly and that Jewish and Arab populations were not going anywhere. Joint List MK Ahmad Tibi answered at the time that there was a button that would remove Kahana from the government. Four years later Tibi’s camp is among the signatures carrying Kahana toward the speaker’s dais.

The Arab lists offered those votes to dump Ohana if the Zionist partners settled on one name. They settled on Kahana. That is enough, on paper, to elect a speaker. It is also the arrangement Liberman says he will not repeat for a cabinet, because a government that lives on Arab abstentions would be easy for Netanyahu to break.

Liberman Takes the Panel That Writes the Draft Law

The Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee is where conscription legislation is thrashed out. The bloc gave that chair to Liberman, who spent years treating Haredi draft exemptions as a reason to walk out of governments. On November 6 he reversed himself in public. Unseating Netanyahu, he said, would take “painful” understandings with Haredi parties, including on the enlistment law.

“It’s painful for me, and I know it’s painful for many others,” Liberman said. “We need to make the maximum effort to form a coalition of 61 lawmakers, without the Joint List and Ra’am.” He pointed back to a 2018 outline he floated as defense minister, a bill with delayed financial sanctions and no personal penalties for men who do not enlist. Ultra-Orthodox negotiators have been described as wanting a one-year, perhaps 18-month, pause with no real enlistment, sanctions, or arrests while a longer framework is written.

Eisenkot has said he is not folding on service for all. The two positions cannot both be fully true if UTJ and Shas are the path to 61. Liberman’s new chair is where that contradiction will be drafted into clauses.

On November 11 the plenum approved the Arrangements Committee 63-50. Folkman chairs it, as the law assigns that panel to the faction of the member Herzog tasked with forming a government. The 22 seats were split 9 for Eisenkot’s camp, 9 for Netanyahu’s, and 4 for the Arab lists, one Arrangements seat for every five Knesset members. The committee then voted 13-9 to recommend Liberman and Avisar Ben Horin as temporary chairs of 17-member Foreign Affairs and Defense and Finance panels.

THE BLOC’S OPENING POSTS

PostNomineeList
SpeakerMatan KahanaYashar
Arrangements CommitteeRoi FolkmanYashar
Foreign Affairs and Defense, temporaryAvigdor LibermanYisrael Beytenu
Finance, temporaryLiran Avisar Ben HorinB’Yachad

Likud’s Ofir Katz had wanted a tighter ratio that would have kept a Jewish majority on Arrangements and denied the Arab lists a fourth seat. Folkman’s ratio passed instead. Katz later said Liberman did not want to look as if Arab votes had installed him at the defense table. The 13-9 tally installed him anyway, with those votes in the room.

A First-Time MK Gets the Finance Gavel

Avisar Ben Horin is fifth on Bennett’s list, a first-term member, and, if the recommendation holds, the first woman to chair the Finance Committee. She ran the Communications Ministry as director general from 2020 to 2023. Bennett hailed the appointment as a first. The panel writes the budget trail and tax bills and has to sign off on many transfers of public money, which is why the chair matters before any government is sworn.

The appointment drew an ethics fight on day one. She is married to Itai Ben-Horin, who holds a 50 percent stake in Ben-Horin Alexandrovitz, a public relations and crisis firm whose clients include Mizrahi Tefahot Bank, Teva, Strauss, and other large companies. Knesset rules require members to disclose a personal interest in a debate, not to sign the kind of conflict agreement used in the civil service. In the Arrangements debate she said the conflict rules that bind ministers do not bind the Knesset. Critics still want her off files that touch her husband’s clients. The 13-9 vote went through with that argument on the table.

Haredi Parties Hold the 13 Seats a Cabinet Still Needs

Take United Torah Judaism’s 7 and Shas’s 6 out of Netanyahu’s 53 and his camp falls to 40. Add them to Eisenkot’s 48 and the sum is 61. That is the only Zionist route to a majority that does not run through the Joint List and Ra’am. Shas recommended Netanyahu to Herzog. United Torah Judaism recommended no one. Without Shas, Eisenkot plus UTJ is 55, still short.

Liberman told Eisenkot that Netanyahu wants them to build with the Arab lists, because that house would be unstable, and that a government with the Haredim is the outcome that would actually last. Eisenkot has invited Likud and Bezalel Smotrich’s Religious Zionism to join a “national emergency government.” He has not invited Itamar Ben-Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit. Herzog, handing over the mandate, told him to build a government that would serve people who had not voted for it.

The Haredi street is not waiting quietly. On November 11, protesters blocked a road outside Beit Shemesh and the light rail on Jaffa Street in Jerusalem after yeshiva students were detained for failing to enlist. Three students were jailed. Rabbi Hirsch, asked about a deal with Eisenkot’s camp, put legal status for yeshiva students ahead of restoring funds. “The most important thing right now is for the yeshiva students to be legal,” he said. Both sides said no formal negotiations were underway. Moshe Gafni, a former Degel HaTorah leader, has been working to stop United Torah Judaism from joining.

THE ROAD TO THE SPEAKER VOTE

  1. October 27, 2026: Voters return a 53-48-19 Knesset and no 61-seat camp.
  2. November 6, 2026: Liberman says a cabinet of 61 without Arab lists will require a painful draft compromise.
  3. November 8, 2026: Herzog tasks Eisenkot with forming a government, 28 days on the clock.
  4. November 10, 2026: The 26th Knesset is sworn in; 67 members ask Ohana to schedule a speaker vote and name Kahana.
  5. November 11, 2026: The plenum approves Arrangements 63-50; the panel recommends Liberman and Avisar Ben Horin 13-9.
  6. November 17, 2026: Plenary debate and vote on a new speaker, 4 p.m.

Kahana can take the gavel if those 67 names hold on the floor. He cannot hand Eisenkot a government. The 13 Haredi seats still sit with rabbis who want yeshiva students made legal, and with a nominee whose last turn in the Religious Services Ministry was spent loosening their grip. The 19 Arab seats already wrote his name on the speaker request, after he once said he would press a button to send them to Switzerland.

Ohana keeps the chair until 4 p.m. on November 17. Eisenkot’s first window to form a government closes on December 6.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending