Connect with us

NEWS

Israel Already Tried Direct Elections for Prime Minister

Change-bloc parties are studying a direct prime minister vote after the October deadlock, a tool Israel used, then scrapped, and that still needs 61 Knesset votes.

Published

on

Israel’s change-bloc parties are studying a direct vote for prime minister, a fix the country already tried and then repealed. Senior figures have labelled the idea the Netanyahu 2021 model. Neither Benjamin Netanyahu’s camp nor Gadi Eisenkot’s won a Knesset majority on October 27.

The same seat count that blocked a coalition still blocks the Basic Law change a direct vote would need. President Isaac Herzog tasked Eisenkot, the Yashar leader and former IDF chief, with forming a government on November 8. The bill remains one option among several, not a decision.

The Change Bloc’s Netanyahu 2021 Model

Michael Hauser Tov’s Friday night television report on October 30 said senior figures in the change bloc confirmed they are examining a direct contest for premier. They want a minority cabinet that does not depend on Arab parties, and they do not want a unity deal with Netanyahu. Opposition parties did not comment in public.

The model they named is the one Netanyahu pushed after the inconclusive March 2021 election, when his own coalition math stalled. In that version, voters would pick a prime minister in a special race and leave the sitting Knesset in place. A winner could, in theory, try to govern without 61 seats. The report said no decision had been taken, and that this was one idea among others.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The pitch: A popular vote for prime minister, kept separate from the party lists that fill the Knesset.
  • The aim: A minority cabinet that does not rest on Ra’am or the Joint List, and does not take Netanyahu in.
  • The label: Change-bloc sources called it the Netanyahu 2021 model, after the bill Shas filed and Netanyahu backed that spring.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • The candidate: Yashar’s Eisenkot, B’Yachad’s Naftali Bennett, and Yisrael Beiteinu’s Avigdor Liberman all sought the top job before October 27, and no joint nominee has been named.
  • The text: No draft has been published, so it is unclear whether the race would be a one-off like 2001 or a standing two-ballot system like 1996.
  • The votes: No party has said it will sponsor the bill, and no whip count exists.

A direct ballot would still count Arab votes for a change-bloc premier. It would not put those parties in the cabinet. That split is the point of the design, and it is the same split that hollowed out Labor and Likud the last time Israel ran this experiment.

48 Seats Cannot Amend a Basic Law

The Central Elections Committee’s final official results and the allocation of the 120 seats left three camps, none of them a majority. Netanyahu’s outgoing partners hold 53. Eisenkot’s four Jewish-led lists hold 48. The Joint List and Ra’am hold a record 19. Turnout was 77.9%, the highest in decades. The electoral threshold stayed at 3.25%.

THE 26TH KNESSET BY BLOC

BlocParties and seatsTotalGap to 61
Netanyahu campLikud 27, Otzma Yehudit 7, United Torah Judaism 7, Shas 6, Religious Zionism 6538 short
Change blocYashar 21, B’Yachad 12, Democrats 8, Yisrael Beiteinu 74813 short
Arab-led listsJoint List 11, Ra’am 819–

Those 19 seats, up from 10 in the outgoing Knesset, are the only pool that turns 48 into 67. Netanyahu’s partners held 68 seats before the vote and now sit eight short of 61. Amending Basic Law: The Government, which is how a direct vote would have to enter the system, still takes at least 61 members. The change bloc would have those 61 only if the Arab lists helped, or if some of Netanyahu’s partners crossed. The first path is the one the bill is meant to avoid. The second path is ordinary coalition bargaining, which does not need a new electoral system.

Herzog’s consultations made the same split visible in another form. Factions totaling 67 members recommended Eisenkot for the mandate. Factions totaling 46 recommended Netanyahu. United Torah Judaism’s 7 recommended no one. Recommendations are not a cabinet. The 19 Arab seats that completed Eisenkot’s 67 were offered to stop Netanyahu, not to sit in government with him.

Split Tickets Hollowed Out Labor and Likud

Israel is the only established democracy that has run a direct popular vote for prime minister. The Knesset wrote it into a new Basic Law: The Government in 1992. The first contest was on May 29, 1996. Voters got two slips, one for premier and one for a party list. The point, as the Foreign Ministry explained at the time, was to cut the hold of small factions that had extracted a high price for coalition support.

Voters did the opposite. They backed a Labor or Likud premier and then handed their Knesset slip to a sectoral list. Labor fell from 44 seats in 1992 to 34. Even after absorbing Tsomet and Gesher, Likud’s combined list won 32. Eleven parties entered the Knesset. Emanuele Ottolenghi later set out why direct election failed in Israel: the double ballot produced split tickets, weaker large parties, and coalitions that were harder to assemble, not easier.

HOW THE 1996 DOUBLE BALLOT SPLIT

RacePerson or listVotesShare or seats
Prime ministerBenjamin Netanyahu1,501,02350.5%
Prime ministerShimon Peres1,471,56649.5%
Knesset listLabor818,74134 seats
Knesset listLikud-Gesher-Tsomet767,40132 seats

Netanyahu’s 29,457-vote margin in 1996 made him premier. It did not make Likud the largest party. Peres drew about 1.47 million personal votes while Labor drew 818,741 Knesset votes. Netanyahu drew 1.50 million while his list drew 767,401. Yossi Beilin and Uzi Landau moved to cancel the system as soon as those numbers landed.

Ehud Barak beat Netanyahu on May 17, 1999, with 56.08% of the vote and a lead of 388,546. He then had to build a cabinet from a Knesset that had grown more fragmented, not less. That cabinet lasted about a year and a half. A special prime-minister-only race on February 6, 2001, after Barak resigned, produced Ariel Sharon from the same sitting Knesset. The dual-ballot years and the one-off 2001 race are different machines. Both still left the winner hunting for partners in the 120-seat house.

We don’t need Ra’am. We need direct elections so that we can form a government.

Benjamin Netanyahu, prime minister, April 2021 press conference

Netanyahu reached for the same lever in April 2021, after another tie. Shas filed a bill for a snap premier race without dissolving the Knesset. He told his faction it was absurd for Naftali Bennett, then sitting on seven seats, to become prime minister, and he claimed a winner would “automatically” set up a government, as in Japan, New Zealand, Norway, and Portugal. Basic Law: The Government said otherwise then, and it says otherwise now: the government serves by virtue of Knesset confidence. The 2021 bill never got 61 votes. Bennett later did take the premiership, in a rotation cabinet that won investiture 60-59 with one abstention.

Why Israel Repealed Direct Elections in 2001

Hours before Sharon was sworn in, the Knesset killed the standing system. The amendment passed on March 7, 2001, 72 to 37 with 3 abstentions, and took effect at the 2003 Knesset election. Labor and Likud both backed the repeal. They had written the reform to strengthen the premier against small parties, then watched those parties grow on the second ballot. President Moshe Katsav called the direct ballot damaging to political stability. Israel went back to a single party vote, with the president assigning a formateur and the Knesset voting confidence.

FROM ENACTMENT TO REPEAL

  1. March 1992: The Knesset adopts a new Basic Law: The Government and sets a direct popular vote for prime minister, to begin at the next election.
  2. May 29, 1996: The first dual ballot is held. Netanyahu beats Peres by 29,457 votes. Labor and the Likud-led list shrink, and 11 parties take seats.
  3. May 17, 1999: Barak beats Netanyahu with 56.08%. The Knesset stays fragmented, and his coalition unravels in about 18 months.
  4. December 19, 2000: The Knesset amends the law so a candidate for a special premier race need not be a sitting MK, opening a path for Netanyahu, who then stays out.
  5. February 6, 2001: A premier-only election, with no new Knesset vote, elects Sharon from the sitting parliament.
  6. March 7, 2001: The Knesset repeals the direct-election law 72 to 37 with 3 abstentions, effective at the 2003 parliamentary election.
  7. April 2021: Shas files a one-off premier bill. Netanyahu backs it. It dies for lack of 61 votes.
  8. October 30, 2026: Change-bloc figures tell a Friday night studio the same model is again under study.

A 2026 one-off, if that is what they write, would not reprint the 1996 double ballot. It would look more like February 2001: pick a person, keep this Knesset. That is the version that does not, by itself, re-fragment the party map. It also does not, by itself, create a cabinet. Sharon still had to stitch eight parties together from the house he inherited. A 2026 winner would face the same 53-48-19 map the voters just drew.

Israel Already Swears In Cabinets Without 61 Yes Votes

The change bloc is hunting a legal shortcut around 61. The Israel Democracy Institute’s reading of the present Basic Law is that it does not require 61 yes votes to take office. The text says the government is constituted when the Knesset has expressed confidence in it. In parliamentary practice, a simple majority of votes cast is enough. Abstentions drop out of the tally. The institute’s example is a cabinet sworn in 54 to 52 with 14 members abstaining or absent. The 2021 change government won 60 to 59 with one abstention.

As of August 2026, 8 of 26 OECD parliamentary democracies were sitting as minority cabinets, including Norway, Denmark, the Netherlands, Spain, and Sweden. In Israel, knocking a sitting cabinet over still takes 61 members behind an alternative government, the constructive no-confidence rule. Dissolving the Knesset also takes 61. A minority cabinet can enter, and it can last, if enough rivals stay off the floor or stay in their seats.

PATHS THAT DO NOT REQUIRE A NEW BASIC LAW

  • UTJ abstention: If United Torah Judaism’s 7 sit out a confidence vote, Netanyahu’s remaining 46 face Eisenkot’s 48, and a change-bloc cabinet can win without Arab yes votes.
  • Outside support: Ra’am or the Joint List can vote yes, or stay away, without taking ministries, the pattern of the Rabin years and of Ra’am’s 2021-22 arrangement.
  • A unity deal: Likud without Netanyahu, or with him, remains the largest list at 27 and is the arithmetic that actually crosses 61 if anyone in the 53 will move.

Eisenkot has set tests for partners that cut against several of those paths at once: recognition of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state, acceptance of the Declaration of Independence, mandatory service for all, and a hard line that Hamas is a terror group to be dismantled. Joint List factions reject the Jewish-state formula. Haredi parties reject a universal draft. Liberman has ruled out a cabinet that depends on Arab parties. The Democrats have resisted a cabinet that excludes them. Those vetoes, not the absence of a popular ballot for premier, are why 67 recommendations have not become 61 seats.

Eisenkot Has Until December 6

Herzog formally handed Eisenkot the mandate on November 8 at the President’s Residence. The first 28 days run through December 6. Herzog may add up to 14 days, which would push the cutoff to December 20. If Eisenkot fails, the president can try another member, with 28 days and no extra time. If that also fails, 61 members can ask the president to assign one of their own for 14 days. After that the Knesset dissolves. The new house was sworn in on November 10, while Netanyahu remains caretaker premier.

Eisenkot used the handover to call for a broad emergency cabinet and to say every party would have to give ground. He has courted Haredi lists, Arab-led lists, and even Likud. Netanyahu has talked up a unity government on terms that keep him in the building. On the Knesset’s first day, the change bloc filed bills for an October 7 state inquiry and to roll back the judicial overhaul. That is not a direct-election law. None of it needs one.

A popular vote for premier would still leave this Knesset in its seats. It would still leave the confidence rule in the Basic Law, unless 61 members agree to rewrite that too. Those 61, on present numbers, are the change bloc plus the Arab lists, or a deal with part of the 53. Israel has already lived through the version of this idea that split the ballot, and the version that picked a person and left the house untouched. The first was repealed 72 to 37. The second still ended in coalition math. The December 6 clock is running on that math, not on a new ballot.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending