NEWS
Court Lists Filibeck Videos After 115 Speakers Were Barred
The Supreme Court will list a plea to take down Giacomo Filibeck’s Hyderabad slogan videos, after India had already blocked 115 of 315 foreign speakers.
The Supreme Court on November 18 agreed to list a plea seeking removal of videos of Italian politician Giacomo Filibeck chanting an Opposition slogan in Hyderabad. Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, sitting with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, said the matter would go before an appropriate bench on Friday, November 20.
The clip is four days old. The guest list fight is older. Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said 115 of 315 foreign speakers already cleared by the external affairs ministry were refused entry or had their visas cancelled before the summit opened, apparently on home ministry instructions.
The Clip the Court Agreed to List
Filibeck, secretary general of the Party of European Socialists, spoke on November 14 at the closing of the two-day Bharat Summit in Hyderabad. Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and Telangana Chief Minister A. Revanth Reddy were on the dais. Filibeck raised “Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod,” then rendered it in English as “Vote thief, leave your seat.”
Rahul Gandhi has defended a simple principle on which every democracy rests; ‘one person, one vote’. His campaign for clean and transparent voter rolls and the thousands who marched with him to Ramlila Maidan just two weeks ago remind us that democracy is not given. It is defended by people willing to stand up for it. ‘Vote Chor Gaddi Chhod’.
Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary General, Party of European Socialists, Bharat Summit, Hyderabad
He added that the Congress had built the democratic foundation of modern India. On the sidelines he went further, saying democracy was under attack in India and that the way to defend it was to stand by Gandhi and the Congress. The petition’s transcript records a third line: “We stand by Rahul Gandhi, the Indian Congress party in defending the democracy in India.”
The slogan is the Opposition’s attack on the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, the drive that has had names struck off voter lists. Filibeck never named the prime minister. Union minister Kiren Rijiju still treated the laughter on the dais as an insult to the country. “Have you ever seen anyone laughing when India is insulted by a foreigner?” he wrote. “I’m not asking about which Indian goes abroad to insult India.”
Advocate Rizwan, mentioning the plea, called the remarks interference in India’s domestic politics by a foreign political representative. He asked for urgent takedown directions because the video was circulating. BJP national spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia labelled the gathering an “Anti-India Summit.” Telangana BJP president N. Ramchander Rao said the Italian had “purposefully” repeated a false Congress line and had interfered in domestic politics.

More Than 100 Speakers Never Reached Hyderabad
The Court is being asked to police a speech that survived a much larger screen. Tharoor, in Hyderabad on November 13, said 115 of the 315 speakers the external affairs ministry had cleared never got in. “It is completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step,” he wrote, “but it is obviously impossible to reverse it since the conference concludes tomorrow.” He added: “What a shame that a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical!”
External affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal would not confirm the total. “Visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government,” he said. The home ministry has not put out its own figure.
THE SPEAKER COUNTS THE CENTRE WILL NOT CONFIRM
| Who gave the figure | What was counted | The number |
|---|---|---|
| Shashi Tharoor | Speakers already cleared by the external affairs ministry who were refused entry or had visas cancelled | 115 of 315 |
| Pushparaj Deshpande, Samruddha Bharat Foundation | Foreign delegates who had confirmed, then could not come | 116 to 117 of 323 |
| Summit organisers | People who still attended, and countries represented | More than 1,000 from over 70 countries |
| Randhir Jaiswal, MEA | Official confirmation of those totals | No figure released |
Those are not two versions of one headcount. Tharoor was counting speakers who had political clearance. Deshpande, who curated the event, was counting confirmed foreign delegates. 115 of 315 is more than a third of that speaker list. The people who did arrive still filled a hall of more than 1,000 from over 70 countries.
Deshpande said the missing guests had followed MEA guidelines and already held political clearances, which were then rescinded. “The visas were denied,” he said. “We have lost almost 116, 117 delegates.” Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng Svendsen said the Indian embassy in Oslo rang about ten minutes before her flight. She had a visa. “Orders from above in the ministry of home affairs have cancelled my visa,” she said.
Some of those who landed were held at immigration, asked about their politics, and told to hand over their phones, according to accounts passed to the organisers by policymakers from Malaysia, Brazil and the Philippines. Revanth Reddy, asked about the blocks, said he did not understand why the BJP was “worried about diverse oppositional voices.”
Manila Blacklisted the Same Man in 2018
The Italian on the Hyderabad dais is not new to this argument. On April 15, 2018, Philippine immigration stopped Giacomo Filibeck at Mactan-Cebu International Airport and deported him the same day. He was then deputy secretary general of the same European socialist party, flying in as a tourist to an Akbayan party congress in Cebu, a sister outfit of his own.
Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra said Filibeck, as a tourist, was not allowed to engage in partisan political activity, and that he had been put on a blacklist for violating immigration law. Immigration Commissioner Jaime Morente said a foreign tourist does not enjoy political rights reserved to Filipinos, and pointed to an operations order that tells foreign visitors to observe those limits. Filibeck had been in the country in October 2017 on a mission that denounced killings in Rodrigo Duterte’s drug campaign. About 20 other foreign delegates on the same Cebu trip were let in. He was not.
PES president Sergei Stanishev called the 2018 expulsion outrageous and said his political family was on the front line of a human-rights fight. Indian officials now say Filibeck entered this time on a conference visa obtained through the e-visa portal, that foreign nationals may not interfere in India’s domestic politics whatever the visa, and that he has since gone back to Italy. No public order has confirmed a new Indian blacklist.
Manila’s file turned on tourist status and a prior human-rights mission. Hyderabad’s file turns on a conference visa and a campaign slogan spoken with Gandhi in the room. The man is the same. The legal wrapper is not.
What India’s Conference Visa Restricts
The petition leans on the home ministry’s own conference-visa FAQ, which is stricter on paper than a tourist stamp and narrower than a political blank cheque. A conference visa is for a foreigner whose sole objective is to attend the conference, seminar or workshop. Missions may issue it on an invitation from a government body, a public university, or, after a background check, an NGO or private host.
WHERE A CONFERENCE VISA STOPS
- The sole aim: The visit must be to attend that conference, not to look for business, work or study on the side.
- Sensitive subjects: The visa is refused for politically sensitive subjects when the proposed event involves politically or socially sensitive material.
- Undesirable persons: It is also refused if the applicant is on a blacklist, a warning circular or another restrictive list, or is treated as undesirable.
- Wrong purpose: It is refused where there is reasonable ground to suspect the stated objective is a cover.
Political clearance is a separate stamp. The external affairs ministry runs an online portal for political clearances so organisers can register foreign names for conferences, seminars, workshops and sports events. Tharoor’s complaint, and Deshpande’s, is that this clearance was given and then the home ministry pulled the visas anyway. Jaiswal’s answer treats that pull as sovereignty, not as a rule that has to be read out in public.
A note dated 28 March 1958, held in the Nehru Archive, drew a harder line for party events. Outsiders coming specifically to attend a national conference of an Indian political party would, the note said, encourage participation in internal politics, which is why a 1958 bar on visas for party conferences was put in place, to be applied as impartially as possible. A person already in India for another purpose could still walk into such a meeting. A visa issued for the meeting itself was the problem.
That is the seam this case sits on. If Hyderabad was a state-hosted international conference, a conference visa is the ordinary door. If it was a Congress campaign stage with a foreign party official on the microphone, the 1958 logic is the one the BJP wants applied after the fact. The petition asks the Court to inspect Filibeck’s visa category, the conditions on it, and the clearances granted for his seat on that dais.
Telangana Put Its Seal on a Campaign Stage
The official programme named the Telangana government as host and the Samruddha Bharat Foundation as curator. Chief Minister Revanth Reddy, Deputy Chief Minister Mallu Bhatti Vikramarka and ministers including D. Sridhar Babu sat on the organising line. The foundation’s director, Pushparaj Deshpande, said he had helped organise the summit under Revanth Reddy, with guidance from Salman Khurshid, Sam Pitroda and Gandhi, as a Global South platform for progressives. Sessions ran at the Hyderabad International Convention Centre and HITEX on November 13 and 14, the second edition, billed as Forging a New World, and timed to Jawaharlal Nehru’s 137th birth anniversary and 80 years of Independence.
Gandhi addressed the valedictory. Filibeck praised the street protests over the Special Intensive Revision, naming students, young people and Opposition parties and putting Congress and Gandhi “at the heart of that fight.” Rao told reporters that Gandhi and Revanth Reddy laughed and clapped, and he demanded an apology from both. His party filed a complaint with the Foreigners Regional Registration Officer at Shamshabad and another with Telangana Director General of Police C.V. Anand, citing the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, and asking for investigation, deportation and blacklisting if the facts fit.
Congress did not treat the Italian as a trespasser. Spokesperson Girija Shetkar pointed at the 2019 Howdy Modi rally in Houston, where the prime minister had backed Donald Trump before an American election. “Was the slogan ‘Abki baar Trump sarkar’ not a comment on another country’s internal affairs?” she asked. MP Pramod Tiwari said the BJP had no standing to lecture on corruption and should introspect if a foreign visitor was saying such things.
The state seal is what makes the visa file more than a party squabble. A private Congress seminar would have been easier to dismiss as a 1958-style party conference. A government-hosted summit with foreign elected officials is exactly the class of event the conference-visa system was built to process. The slogan then pulled that system into a campaign fight the home ministry had already been waging at the airport.
From the Dais to a Friday Listing
The plea Rizwan mentioned is not a request for a lecture on manners. It asks the Court to supervise an independent special investigation team into how the summit was organised, what permissions foreign delegates received, what visa conditions applied, and what government authorities and organisers did. It wants records and communications preserved and produced. It wants identified videos taken down by Meta on Facebook and Instagram, by X Corp. on X, and by Google on YouTube, with the originals, URLs, account details, upload data, timestamps and metadata kept. It wants a public apology from the Telangana government and written undertakings that future events will not be used to let foreign delegates join domestic partisan activity in breach of law or visa conditions.
The petitioner says this is not a blanket gag on political talk online, only on the specified clips. By the time that prayer reached the Chief Justice, the clips had already been replayed by parties, channels and ministers. A takedown order would not unsay the slogan in Hyderabad. It would test whether a foreign party official’s campaign chant, spoken on a state stage, can be treated as content the platforms must bury.
FROM HYDERABAD TO THE SUPREME COURT
- April 15, 2018: Philippine immigration denies Filibeck entry at Mactan-Cebu International Airport and deports him the same day for partisan political activity as a tourist.
- November 13, 2026: The Bharat Summit opens in Hyderabad. Tharoor says 115 of 315 cleared speakers are out. Jaiswal calls visas a sovereign function.
- November 14, 2026: Filibeck raises “Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod” at the valedictory, with Gandhi and Revanth Reddy on the dais.
- November 15, 2026: Rijiju attacks the laughter on the dais. In Italy, Forza Italia’s Deborah Bergamini criticises Filibeck for lecturing India.
- November 16, 2026: Telangana BJP files complaints with the FRRO and the DGP seeking action against Filibeck and the organisers.
- November 18, 2026: A Supreme Court bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant agrees to list the takedown and SIT plea for Friday, November 20.
Government officials said Filibeck had already left India. Deportation, the remedy Rao wanted on Monday, is no longer a live physical fact. What remains is the record: the visa category, the political clearances, the state government’s role as host, and the videos the petition wants gone. The SIT prayer would pull the home ministry’s unpublished visa file into a Court-supervised probe of the same event the ministry had already thinned at the gate.
A Meloni Ally Told Europe to Stop Lecturing India
Rome did not close ranks behind the socialist. Deborah Bergamini, national deputy secretary of Forza Italia, a party in Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s coalition, called Filibeck’s intervention inappropriate in the domestic debate of a friendly country with which Italy has a special strategic partnership.
It is inappropriate to lecture on democracy a nation that enables 970 million citizens to vote. India possesses its own political institutions and judiciary; any conflicts or disputes should be addressed and resolved in accordance with the established rules of democracy.
Deborah Bergamini, national deputy secretary, Forza Italia
She described the Hyderabad line as an attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s BJP by an Italian from the European Socialists and Democrats group, and tied it to the Opposition’s fight over a revision of electoral rolls meant, in her telling, to remove duplicates, the dead and people who have moved. The 970 million figure is hers. India’s dispute over the rolls sits in its own commission and courts, which is the point she was making and the point the BJP wants written onto a foreign visitor’s visa.
The louder demand after the clip was the one Manila had already carried out: cancel the stay, put the name on a list, send the man home. That demand arrived late. Filibeck was gone. The videos were not. The Supreme Court is now being asked to do the leftover work, on a speech that passed a visa screen the Union had spent the same week tightening, and on a politician another Asian government had already turned back at the airport in 2018.
Chief Justice Surya Kant said the plea would be listed on Friday, November 20, before an appropriate bench.
NEWS2 months agoClancy Juror Says the Holdout Never Cited Evidence
NEWS3 months agoThe iPhone 18 Pro Max Splits Apple’s Fall in Two
NEWS3 months agoOpenAI Calls GPT-6 Astra AGI Then Locks Its Exploits
BUSINESS3 months agoTrump Claims Hormuz Control as Oil Holds Near $96
LIFESTYLE3 months agoRussia Closes the Goethe-Institut Berlin Tried to Save
AUTO3 months agoVolkswagen’s Job Cuts Leave Four Plants Without Cars
NEWS3 months agoDyson Puts Nurovi Robots on Sale Without the UV Flagship
BUSINESS2 months agoUS Destroys Five Iranian Tankers as the Shock Hits Jordan













