Connect with us

BUSINESS

SBI Share Targets Split After a One-Off Profit Jump

SBI share price targets run from Rs 1,100 to Rs 1,350 after Q2 profit that included a Rs 7,288 crore listing gain.

Published

on

UBS and Nomura kept State Bank of India at Neutral with Rs 1,100 targets after a quarter whose 14.28% profit jump included a Rs 7,288 crore listing gain. Jefferies repeated a Buy at Rs 1,320, and Emkay Global Financial Services went to Rs 1,350, which from Rs 988 is 34% and 37% upside.

Shares of SBI rose about 2% to Rs 988 on the BSE on Wednesday, November 4, after closing at Rs 969.55 when the numbers hit on Tuesday. The SBI share price target argument is not a single Buy call. It is a Rs 250 gap between those two camps, and it starts with what sat inside the profit.

Headline Profit Rode a Rs 7,288 Crore Sale

SBI reported a Q2 net profit of Rs 23,038 crore, up 14.28% from Rs 20,160 crore a year earlier, and net interest income of Rs 49,143 crore, up 14.69%. Interest income rose 10.46% to Rs 1.32 lakh crore, while interest expenses grew 8.09% to Rs 82,876 crore. Loan-loss provisions fell 33.23% to Rs 2,759 crore, and the gross NPA ratio dropped to 1.39% from 1.73%, which the bank’s own slides called the lowest in more than two decades.

The operating-profit line that SBI printed was Rs 34,226 crore, up 7.28%. That figure includes a Rs 7,288 crore gain on the sale of a slice of SBI Funds Management, which listed on July 21 at Rs 613 against an issue price of Rs 574. Take the gain out and the pre-provision operating line is Rs 26,937 crore, down 1.37% from Rs 27,311 crore a year ago. The listing item was about 24% of pre-tax profit of Rs 30,009 crore. Strip last year’s Rs 4,593 crore exceptional item as well, and pre-tax profit still rose only about 3.7%.

Q2FY27 STANDALONE SCORECARD

LineQ2FY27Q2FY26Change
Net profitRs 23,038 croreRs 20,160 crore+14.28%
Net interest incomeRs 49,143 croreRs 42,847 crore+14.69%
Operating profit as reportedRs 34,226 croreRs 31,904 crore+7.28%
Loan-loss provisionsRs 2,759 croreRs 4,132 crore-33.23%
Gross NPA ratio1.39%1.73%-34 bps
Net NPA ratio0.36%0.42%-6 bps
Credit cost0.22%0.39%-17 bps
CET-1 ratio13.34%11.47%+187 bps

Group net profit rose 19.7% to Rs 25,741 crore. Half-year return on assets was 1.14% and return on equity 18.68%, both as SBI reported them, with the funds-management gain inside the half. Proceeds from SBI’s sale of National Stock Exchange shares in that exchange’s public offer went to reserves and did not run through the profit-and-loss account.

A Rs 250 Gap Between Buy and Neutral

Jefferies kept SBI among its top banking picks at 1.5 times estimated December 2028 adjusted book, and raised FY27 to FY29 estimates by 1-2%. It still wants core profit to compound at 14% from FY26 to FY29, with return on assets of 1% and return on equity of 15% in FY28. Motilal Oswal Fine-tuned FY27 and FY28 numbers and landed at Rs 1,225, or 1.3 times March 2028 adjusted book plus Rs 281 for subsidiaries, implying 24% from Rs 988. Emkay held Rs 1,350, or 1.4 times September 2028 adjusted book plus Rs 318 for subsidiaries and investments.

Those three notes are the Buy chorus that followed the print. They are not the whole tape. UBS and Nomura both sat at Neutral with Rs 1,100, which is 11% above Rs 988. Goldman Sachs cut its target to Rs 1,130 from Rs 1,190 and stayed Neutral. HSBC kept a Buy but cut its target to Rs 1,220 from Rs 1,310 even after lifting FY27 to FY29 earnings estimates by 4-8%, citing slower loan growth and lower multiples on some subsidiaries. Morgan Stanley stayed Equalweight at Rs 1,135. JP Morgan raised an Overweight target only to Rs 1,295 from Rs 1,280.

BROKER TARGETS FROM RS 988

HouseRatingTarget (Rs)Upside
Emkay GlobalBuy1,35037%
JefferiesBuy1,32034%
CLSAOutperform1,32534%
CitiBuy1,30032%
Motilal OswalBuy1,22524%
HSBCBuy1,22023%
Goldman SachsNeutral1,13014%
UBSNeutral1,10011%

UBS called the quarter mixed: NII up 5% quarter on quarter and the whole-bank net interest margin at 2.94%, up 8 basis points, both ahead of its model, against an 18.2% loan book (slower than 19% in the June quarter) and a 3% miss on pre-provision operating profit because costs ran hot. It also booked a Rs 1,280 crore treasury loss against the Rs 7,288 crore funds-management gain. Take the listing gain out, UBS said, and half-year return on assets falls below 1% against the reported 1.14%.

Bernstein, at Market Perform with a Rs 1,300 target, ran a similar screen on the quarter itself. Excluding one-offs, it had earnings per share up 5% year on year and return on assets down 21 basis points quarter on quarter to 0.90%, against reported EPS growth of 13% and a 1.19% return on assets. Citi, still a Buy at Rs 1,300, flagged opex up 15% year on year and 38% quarter on quarter. The Tuesday tape, which sold the stock 1.77% to Rs 969.55, priced that gap before the Buy notes had time to circulate.

The $10.9 Billion Liability Swap

Domestic net interest margin rose 11 basis points quarter on quarter to 3.11%, and 3 basis points year on year. The whole-bank margin for the quarter was 2.94%, up 8 basis points from June. Chairman C.S. Setty tied the lift to a cheaper liability mix, not a sudden jump in loan yields alone. SBI raised $10.9 billion of Foreign Currency Non-Resident (Bank) deposits through the concessional swap window the Reserve Bank of India opened in June, about Rs 95,000 crore, and used the money to retire high-cost borrowings.

In this quarter, around 95,000 crores equivalent in rupees was garnered in FCNR-B deposits. So, in the overall deposit portfolio, it doesn’t add up as much and hence it’s not pulling down our NIM.

C.S. Setty, Chairman, SBI, post-earnings briefing

That pile is about 1.51% of a Rs 62.78 lakh crore deposit book, which grew 12.27% year on year. Strip the FCNR money out and Setty put deposit growth at 10.5% to 10.6%, in line with the bank’s 10-11% full-year deposit goal. CASA deposits grew 8.13%, and the CASA ratio slipped to 38.32% from 39.63% a year earlier. The bank also lent $8.83 billion to those diaspora depositors under the window’s leverage facility, which CLSA said flattered international loan growth; adjusted for FCNR-backed loans, it had international advances down 3% quarter on quarter.

Setty kept domestic NIM guidance above 3% for FY27 and said the latest 25-basis-point repo increase should add 4 to 5 basis points as external-benchmark loans reprice faster than deposits. Citi’s note put 49% of the book on external benchmarks, including 32% linked to the repo. Motilal also pointed to surplus FCNR(B) liquidity being used to cut high-cost liabilities, plus lagged repricing of EBLR and MCLR loans still to come. The margin beat is real. It is also a liability-management print, and the concessional window is not a permanent funding line.

What the ECL Transition Does to Capital

Setty put the net-of-tax hit from moving onto expected credit loss at Rs 19,500 crore. Citi’s note framed that as 3.3% of net worth and 0.4% of advances. The bank will use the four-year transition rather than take the charge in one shot. Jefferies still called asset quality strong, with credit cost at 0.2% of average loans in its write-up, against SBI’s own Q2 credit cost of 0.22% and a slippage ratio of 0.41%. Fresh slippages were Rs 5,227 crore, down from Rs 7,046 crore in the June quarter.

The ECL rules that start in April 2027, issued on April 27, 2026 as the Reserve Bank of India (Commercial Banks – Asset Classification, Provisioning and Income Recognition) Directions, 2026, replace incurred-loss provisioning with a three-stage, forward-looking model. Banks still use the incurred-loss provisioning now in force until that date. On day one they must fair-value the entire loan book, and any gap versus carrying value goes against opening retained earnings, not the profit-and-loss account. A transitional add-back to common equity tier 1 then fades over four years so the capital hit is not taken at once.

ECL SWITCH, AS SBI HAS MODELLED IT

  • The bill: Rs 19,500 crore net of tax, which Citi puts at 3.3% of net worth.
  • The date: April 1, 2027, with models already running inside SBI.
  • The path: four-year transition, not an upfront reserve hit.
  • The accounting: fair-value gap on day one against retained earnings, not quarterly profit.
  • The buffer: CET-1 at 13.34% and CRAR at 16.09% as of September 30, 2026.

Setty said a working group is still arguing nuances with the regulator and that a CEO-level meeting on industry readiness is planned, so the Rs 19,500 crore figure can still move. Clarity is also pending on the annual profit-and-loss run-rate and on held-to-maturity investments, which is the open item Jefferies flagged even while repeating the Buy. Macquarie, at Outperform with a Rs 1,220 target, called the ECL hit manageable. Peers have printed their own bills: Bank of Baroda around Rs 12,500 crore, Canara Bank Rs 12,000 crore to Rs 15,000 crore, Punjab National Bank around Rs 8,000 crore. SBI’s number is larger because the book is larger, at Rs 52.08 lakh crore of gross advances, up 17.84%.

Motilal Puts Rs 281 on the Subsidiaries

Motilal’s Rs 1,225 target is 1.3 times March 2028 adjusted book plus Rs 281 for subsidiaries. Emkay’s Rs 1,350 is 1.4 times September 2028 adjusted book plus Rs 318. Those add-ons are 23% of Motilal’s target and 24% of Emkay’s. Jefferies, which does not split the same way in the note that followed Q2, still listed “the potential to monetise stakes in its businesses” next to the 13% CET-1 ratio (SBI’s own figure is 13.34%) as a support for growth.

The quarter already cashed part of that option. The Rs 7,288 crore funds-management gain is the listed proof, and it will not sit in FY28 earnings. HSBC’s target cut, from Rs 1,310 to Rs 1,220 while earnings estimates went up, is the other side of the same coin: it marked down multiples on some subsidiaries even as it gave the bank credit for a stronger margin. SBI remains the majority owner of the asset manager after the offer for sale, and it still holds SBI Life Insurance and SBI Cards. Motilal has a separate Neutral rating on SBI Cards at Rs 625 after that unit’s own Q2. Government of India ownership of the parent stayed at 55.03%.

Jefferies can count SBI as a top pick because the core bank, at 1.5 times 2028 book, still screens cheap against a 15% FY28 return on equity if that return shows up. Neutral houses are not arguing that the franchise is broken. They are arguing that a 1.14% half-year return that needs a listing gain to clear 1%, and a target that needs Rs 281 to Rs 318 of subsidiary value, is a different security from a clean 1% return-on-assets compounder.

Retail Outside Gold Still Lags the Book

Gross advances stood at Rs 52.08 lakh crore, up 17.84% year on year and 3.19% from June. Retail personal loans grew 14.54% to Rs 18.25 lakh crore, with home loans, at Rs 9.86 lakh crore, up 11.94%. Agriculture grew 22.64% to Rs 4.51 lakh crore, SME loans 21.97%, and domestic corporate 16.12% to Rs 14.39 lakh crore. UBS said retail other than gold stayed weak, and Citi said corporate lending was roughly flat quarter on quarter (SBI’s own sequential corporate figure is +1.30%). The 18% headline growth is RAM- and corporate-year-on-year math, not a broad retail burst.

GROSS ADVANCES BY BOOK, SEPTEMBER 2026

BookAmountYear-on-year
Gross advancesRs 52.08 lakh crore17.84%
Retail personalRs 18.25 lakh crore14.54%
Home loansRs 9.86 lakh crore11.94%
Domestic corporateRs 14.39 lakh crore16.12%
AgricultureRs 4.51 lakh crore22.64%
DepositsRs 62.78 lakh crore12.27%

Setty kept credit growth guidance at 14-15% for FY27, saying 14% to 15% is “something minimum we should achieve,” and deposit growth at 10-11%. He also kept a 50-basis-point credit-cost ceiling and said the bank may not even get there this year, after a 0.22% Q2 print. Citi thinks advances can still run at 16% or more. The agricultural book, 10.31% of domestic advances, is the watch item he named: SBI has identified a Rs 10,000 crore pool that may qualify for restructuring across three drought-hit states, with uptake depending on farmer consent. “Our past experience shows that not many come for the restructuring,” he said. One crop season, he added, does not sour the crop-loan book by itself.

Emkay’s Buy still lists a macroeconomic slowdown and higher treasury losses as the main risks, which is a polite way of saying the Rs 1,280 crore treasury hole in this quarter is not a theoretical line. Kotak Institutional Equities, at Buy with Rs 1,250, called asset quality a minor concern and the valuation inexpensive against a 15% return on equity. That is the bull case in one sentence. The cautious case is also one sentence: from Rs 988, UBS and Nomura will pay 11% more for a bank whose reported 14.28% profit growth was 24% a listing gain, whose pre-provision operating line fell 1.37%, and whose Rs 19,500 crore ECL bill comes due on April 1, 2027.

Wednesday’s bounce to Rs 988 put Jefferies’ 34% back in the window and left the Neutral Rs 1,100 notes 11% above the tape. Both prices are live on the same book.

Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of State Bank of India’s Q2FY27 results and of third-party brokerage targets, and it is for information only. It is not investment advice, a research report, a Buy, Sell or Hold recommendation, or an offer to deal in SBI or any subsidiary. Readers should consult a SEBI-registered research analyst or investment adviser and consider their own risk, horizon and tax position before acting on any target or rating named here. Figures, ratings and guidance are those published by SBI, the Reserve Bank of India and the named brokerages around November 3-4, 2026, and they can change with the next print, the ECL rollout and the rate cycle.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending