Connect with us

NEWS

Delhi’s Emergency Curbs Leave a Three-Year Pollution Peak

CSE finds Delhi’s pre-Diwali PM2.5 at 236 µg/m³, a three-year high, while emergency vehicle curbs left weekday gridlock and night-time NO2 almost unchanged.

Published

on

Delhi averaged 236 µg/m³ of PM2.5 in the week before Diwali, a three-year high and 97% above 2025, CSE said on November 11. Emergency traffic curbs left weekday gridlock almost unchanged, and GRAP Stage III began on November 6 as farm-fire smoke fell to about 8%.

The Centre for Science and Environment built the early-winter post-Diwali analysis from Central Pollution Control Board station feeds, Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology source estimates, Indian Agricultural Research Institute fire counts, and hourly GPS travel times. Anumita Roychowdhury, CSE’s executive director for research and advocacy, said the festival remains an annual tipping point, but the floor under it is now higher.

A Three-Year High in the Week Before Diwali

Sharanjeet Kaur, deputy programme manager in CSE’s Urban Lab, said pre-winter levels in 2026 ran above 2025 except for a brief late-September dip after rain. In both years the load jumped in the days before the festival. The pre-festive week was worse this time.

The 236 µg/m³ week average is 32% above the 179 µg/m³ CSE logged for the same window in 2024, and almost double the 120 µg/m³ of 2025. Against India’s 2009 24-hour PM2.5 standard of 60 µg/m³, 236 is almost four times the cap. Against the 15 µg/m³ 24-hour level in the WHO global air quality guidelines, it is about 16 times the health benchmark.

PRE-DIWALI WEEK PM2.5 IN DELHI

YearWeek-before-Diwali PM2.5CSE comparison
2024179 µg/m³2026 is 32% higher
2025120 µg/m³2026 is 97% higher
2026236 µg/m³Three-year high

On September 30, CSE had already found Delhi logged only one Good air day across 92 days despite 576.9 mm of rain, and warned that winter would start from a high baseline. The pre-Diwali week is that warning in the numbers.

Why Did Stage III Begin as Farm-Fire Smoke Fell?

The Commission for Air Quality Management in NCR and Adjoining Areas invoked Stage III in NCR on November 6 after CPCB’s daily bulletin put Delhi’s AQI at 382, in the Very Poor band, and IMD and IITM forecasts pointed to Severe air in the days ahead. Farm-fire smoke that day was about 8% of citywide PM2.5, down from a season peak of 16.2% on November 4.

Stage I had already begun on October 21. Stage II followed on November 2, the day the city slipped into Very Poor. CSE said stubble’s share was 3.9% while Stage I ran, 11.5% on November 1, and 8.6% on November 2. Severe smog kept arriving after that share dropped.

THE GRAP LADDER THIS WINTER

  1. October 21, 2026: Stage I starts after AQI jumps to 244 from 179 on October 20.
  2. November 1, 2026: Seasonal ban on non-BS-VI vehicles registered outside Delhi begins, through January 31, 2027.
  3. November 2, 2026: AQI enters Very Poor; Stage II starts; stubble share 8.6%.
  4. November 4, 2026: Farm-fire smoke peaks at 16.2% of citywide PM2.5.
  5. November 6, 2026: Stage III starts at AQI 382 as stubble share falls to about 8%.
  6. November 8, 2026: Diwali. Citywide Travel Time Index drops to 1.32.

The revised September GRAP schedule writes Stage III for AQI 401 to 450, the Severe band, and lets the sub-committee move early when forecasts say that band will hold. That is how Stage III arrived at 382.

WHERE EXPERTS DISAGREE

  • CSE and IITM DSS: Stubble averaged 14.29% of Delhi PM2.5 from November 1 to 8, and about 8% on the day Stage III began, so local and NCR emissions carried the episode.
  • Gufran Beig, former SAFAR founder: Satellites miss farm fires after 4 pm, and DSS leans on official fire counts, so the modelled share looks lower than the real plume.
  • Sunil Dahiya, Envirocatalyst founder: The model does not use burnt area, and ground counts of fires have run higher than the official tally.

A thicker farm-fire share would still leave the traffic numbers CSE published for the same week. Those numbers barely moved under the curbs sold as an emergency brake.

Vehicle Curbs Left Weekday Gridlock Untouched

From November 1 the city barred non-BS-VI petrol and diesel vehicles registered outside Delhi, told offices to keep half their staff at home, and doubled parking charges at authorised lots. Stage III then restricted BS-III petrol and BS-IV diesel four-wheelers in Delhi and five NCR districts. CSE said those emergency bars on pre-BS-VI vehicles failed to cut traffic volumes in a serious way.

Shubham Srivastava, deputy programme manager for clean air and sustainable mobility at CSE, compared the restriction week with Friday, October 30, the last working day before the rules bit. Daily and evening travel-time scores stayed within 0.02 of that Friday.

TRAVEL TIME UNDER THE CURBS

  • Daily TTI, November 2 to 6: 2.40, against 2.38 on October 30.
  • Evening peak TTI: 3.49, against 3.48 on October 30.
  • Versus January to April weekdays: trips still took 13% longer, and 13 to 31% longer in the evening peak.
  • Worst hour: TTI 4.2 between 7 pm and 8 pm on November 5.

A Travel Time Index of 2.4 means a trip took 2.4 times as long as the same road between 2 am and 4 am. Morning peaks under the curbs ran 1% slower. Evening peaks stayed flat. Across weekdays, congestion sat 7% above a normal day on Friday, November 6, Dhanteras, and 17% above on November 3 and 4.

The Weekdays Did Not Flatten

CSE’s hourly congestion and NO2 figures show every weekday in the window climbing from 7 am, holding around a TTI of 2.3 through the afternoon, then spiking between 6 pm and 8 pm, when trips took 3.6 to 4.2 times night speed. The rules, Srivastava said, stopped the pre-festive rush getting worse. They did not restore ordinary roads.

Three to five days before Diwali, trips ran about 5% faster than in the same stretch of 2025, when no emergency curbs were in force (average TTI 2.45 against 2.58). Relative to each year’s own baseline, those days still ran 18 to 21% slow in 2026, against 24 to 34% slow in 2025. CSE treated that as a possible mild dampening, and also as a gap that a different year could explain.

Weekends Fell for Other Reasons

Weekends under the rules ran 8% below baseline. Sunday, November 1, coincided with the diesel-truck entry ban and closed offices. Saturday, November 7, Chhoti Diwali, had people at home or out of the city. Saturday, October 31, before the curbs, had surged 22% above a normal weekend and 37% in the evening.

Holi emptied the roads more than Diwali. On March 4 the TTI never topped 1.25 and averaged 1.15, 46% below a normal weekday. Diwali 2026 averaged 1.32, matching Diwali 2025, and sat 29% below a typical Sunday, with an afternoon plateau around 1.5 from last-minute shopping and visits.

The Night Air Holds the Evening Rush

Nitrogen dioxide is CSE’s marker for vehicle exhaust because nearly 80% of it comes from vehicles. From October 30 to November 9, NO2 had a first peak of 56 µg/m³ at 9 am, fell to 29 µg/m³ at 2 pm even while roads stayed packed, then rose with the evening peak to 67 µg/m³ at 7 pm and stayed above 55 µg/m³ until midnight.

In effect, the evening rush loads the air and the still night air keeps it there. Daily NO2 concentrations surged by one-third starting November 2, 2026, even as traffic congestion remained flat.

Sharanjeet Kaur, deputy programme manager, Urban Lab, CSE

Daily average NO2 sat at 33 to 39 µg/m³ from October 30 to November 1, then 46 to 52 µg/m³ from November 2 to 6, about a third higher, on an all-station mean of 59 monitors. Diwali, the least congested day of the window at TTI 1.32, still posted a daily NO2 of 50 µg/m³, with 75 µg/m³ at 9 am and 71 µg/m³ at 10 pm, the firecracker hours.

IITM’s source mix for 1 am to 9 am on November 9, the morning after Diwali, put firecrackers at 71.1% of PM2.5 in that window, with vehicles at 6.9%. That overnight spike sat on the high pre-festival floor CSE measured, it did not create it. Easterly winds on the afternoon of November 9 then thinned the plume across Delhi, Haryana and north-west Uttar Pradesh, Navdeep Dahiya, a meteorologist who tracks the north Indian airshed, wrote that day, calling weather the king maker while stubble smoke stayed bottled in Amritsar, Gurdaspur and Lahore. Wind moved the cloud. The bans had not emptied the weekday roads that built it.

Jahangirpuri Still Leads as New Hotspots Rise

Eleven of Delhi’s 13 official pollution hotspots recorded lower PM2.5 from October 1 to November 8 than in the same stretch of 2025. Anand Vihar fell 49%, Wazirpur 41%, Ashok Vihar 40%, and Bawana 22%. Jahangirpuri rose 2% and stayed the dirtiest designated site at 163 µg/m³. Punjabi Bagh rose 1%.

Sites outside that official list now outrun several of the old names that improved. CSE flagged that Vivek Vihar and DTU already carry heavier PM2.5 loads than some traditional hotspots that dropped.

EMERGING SITES OUTSIDE THE OFFICIAL LIST

  • Vivek Vihar: 144 µg/m³ average from October 1 to November 8.
  • Sonia Vihar: 139 µg/m³.
  • ITO: 137 µg/m³.
  • DTU: 135 µg/m³.
  • NIH Narela: 122 µg/m³.
  • NSUT Jaffarpur: 111 µg/m³.

The same climb showed up across the wider National Capital Region. CSE’s daily PM2.5 calendar is relatively clean through September, then rises through October, then spikes in early November across Delhi, Gurugram, Faridabad, Noida, Ghaziabad and Greater Noida together.

What Share of Delhi PM2.5 Came From NCR Districts?

IITM’s Decision Support System for November 1 to 8 put pollution blown in from neighbouring NCR districts at 54.43% of Delhi’s PM2.5, local sources at 33.06%, and stubble burning at 14.29%. Those three slices are model estimates and sum a little over 100 because of rounding. Among local sources, vehicles led by a wide margin.

LOCAL SOURCES INSIDE DELHI, NOVEMBER 1 TO 8

Local sourceShare of Delhi’s local PM2.5
Vehicular transport52%
Residential activity13%
Peripheral industries11%
Construction7%
Energy use5%
Waste burning5%
Road dust4%
Other sectors4%

Fifty-two percent of the 33.06% local slice is about 17% of citywide PM2.5 from Delhi’s own vehicles. The larger neighbour-district share is why a Delhi-only entry ban, even if it had cleared inner roads, would still leave more than half the particle load untouched. CSE said that even at the peak of the stubble season, regional drift and everyday urban emissions were what kept the air toxic.

CSE’s Case for Cutting Traffic Volume

Roychowdhury said year-round control across the main sources remains inadequate, and that cleaner air heading into winter, with farm fires and crackers held down, would have stopped seasonal weather from setting off such a severe spell. The briefing argues that because those routine controls have slipped, the region now leans harder on GRAP each winter instead of needing it less.

Short-term emergency steps cannot substitute for systemic solutions.

Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director, research and advocacy, CSE

Srivastava said clean-air plans still treat vehicles as a tailpipe and routing problem, not a volume problem. In idle and slow crawl, engines run at inefficient speeds and emit more per kilometre. Conventional traffic engineering and piecemeal emergency rules, he said, cannot absorb that overload, and cuts have to come from mass transit, trip-reduction mandates, and tighter limits on private cars.

On November 5, the Thursday before Stage III, the 7 pm hour already ran at a TTI of 4.2. That crawl is the machine CSE is measuring, and the emergency sticker regime did not switch it off.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do India’s PM2.5 Standards Compare With WHO Guidelines?

India’s 2009 national ambient standards set 40 µg/m³ as the annual PM2.5 limit and 60 µg/m³ as the 24-hour limit. WHO’s 2021 guidelines recommend 5 µg/m³ annual and 15 µg/m³ as the 24-hour level, so the national annual cap is eight times the WHO annual figure.

Which Private Cars Cannot Run Under GRAP Stage III?

BS-III petrol and BS-IV diesel four-wheelers are restricted in Delhi, Gurugram, Faridabad, Ghaziabad, Gautam Buddha Nagar and Sonipat, which was added in the September 2026 revision. Electric and CNG cars, and vehicles adapted for persons with disabilities for personal use, are not covered by this specific car curb.

What Does a Travel Time Index of 2.40 Mean?

CSE defines TTI as trip time in actual traffic divided by free-flow time on empty roads between 2:00 am and 4:00 am. A TTI of 2.4 means a trip took 2.4 times longer than free flow, a 140% increase in travel time.

What Extra Traffic Steps Sat Beside GRAP in Early November?

From November 1, offices were advised to keep 50% of staff on work from home, and parking charges were doubled at authorised sites. Those steps ran with the seasonal bar on outside-Delhi non-BS-VI vehicles, before Stage III added the older petrol and diesel car curb on November 6.

Did Commuters Need Less Buffer Time After the Curbs?

The Planning Time Index, the extra time needed so that 95% of trips still arrive, improved only from 6.36 to 6.16 in evening peaks under the rules. CSE reads that as a marginal change in how much slack a commute still required.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending