Connect with us

BUSINESS

Jindal’s Spare Coking Coal Still Carries a Carbon Bill

Naveen Jindal says Europe’s furnace exit will leave India coking coal, while Tata Steel’s T.V. Narendran says imports will continue.

Published

on

Naveen Jindal said Wednesday that India will have enough coking coal because Europe and the United States are walking away from blast furnaces. He spoke in New Delhi as president of the Indian Steel Association and chairman of Jindal Steel, at the fourth ISA Coking Coal Summit during the seventh ISA Steel Conclave.

Hours later, Tata Steel MD and CEO T.V. Narendran told reporters the same hall that Indian coking coal still fails on quantity and on quality, so mills will stay on imports. The leftover-coal bet and the import trap were offered on the same morning.

The Good Point, as Jindal Tells It

Jindal framed Western furnace closures as a supply windfall for the one large steel industry still lighting new blast furnaces. China, he said, already has huge capacity and is tapering down. India, in his telling, is the exception that keeps building.

World over, in the US and Europe, people are abandoning blast furnaces. If they abandon blast furnaces, there’s going to be enough coking coal for companies in India, because India is the only country that I can think of in the world that is still building blast furnaces.

Naveen Jindal, chairman, Jindal Steel, and president, Indian Steel Association, ISA Coking Coal Summit, New Delhi

He put a date on the European half of that claim. Entire Europe after 2035, he said, is going to move away from blast furnaces, and the United States is pretty much moving away already, so he feels coking coal will be available. That is a forecast about seaborne tonnes a decade out, not a statement that Indian mines can feed Indian ovens now.

His own history cuts against easy comfort. In a post from the inaugural session he wrote that his family once kept away from blast furnaces because of the fear of coking coal imports, that the fear pushed the group toward coal gasification, and that two decades of struggle taught them a lot. He added that coking coal now sits at the heart of India’s steel growth and that building domestic capacity is a priority.

He also told the summit that domestic reserves run high in ash, so the coal has to be washed before it can make coke, and that washing cuts the usable yield. Jindal Steel looked at mines in Australia and Indonesia, ran into trouble in several markets, and found more success in Mozambique, where he said the company is producing around 7-8 million tonnes of coking coal a year. Overseas assets, in his account, remain part of the hedge even if Europe leaves tonnes on the water.

Tata’s Narendran Still Sees an Import Trap

Narendran, speaking to reporters on the sidelines of the same summit, did not argue with the idea that Western mills are shutting coal furnaces. He argued with the idea that India can grow out of the import line.

The availability of coking coal in India is limited by the reserves that we have. So, I don’t think coking coal in India is sufficient to cater to the requirements of the Indian steel industry, both in terms of quantity and in terms of quality. So, we will be dependent on imports.

T.V. Narendran, MD and CEO, Tata Steel, ISA Coking Coal Summit, New Delhi

He kept Australia at the centre of that dependence. The best coking coal available is from Australia, he said, which is why Australia still has more than a 50 per cent share of the coking coal that comes into the country. A steel ministry submission to a parliamentary standing committee put Australia’s share at 54 per cent in 2025, down from 73 per cent in 2019, as Russia, the United States, Mozambique and Indonesia took more of the cargo mix. Diversifying the docks does not change the fact that the docks are still foreign.

Hard coking coal is not a leftover of Europe’s thermal-coal exit. It is a tight spec, low in ash, and the mills that still run large blast furnaces bid for the same cargoes. If Western demand falls after 2035, seaborne tonnes may loosen. They will not wash Indian coal from 34-38 per cent ash down to the 16-18 per cent band that coke ovens need, the range a NITI Aayog note on domestic coking coal has already flagged.

How Much Coking Coal India Still Imports

Provisional figures the Coal Ministry placed in the Lok Sabha show India imported 66.33 million tonnes of coking coal in FY26, up 15.2 per cent from 57.58 million tonnes in FY25. That covered 91.79 per cent of a 72.26 million tonne requirement. Washed domestic coking coal came in at 5.93 million tonnes, or 8.2 per cent of need, against geological coking coal resources estimated at 37.37 billion tonnes. The gap is not a missing mountain. It is a missing wash.

In a separate July 29, 2026 answer, the ministry told the Lok Sabha that around 90 percent of coking coal demand in the steel sector is still met by imports, with about 10 per cent from domestic coal. The July line is the standing ratio; the FY26 tally is the latest full-year count. Joint Plant Committee data cited by the steel ministry put about 41 per cent of Indian crude steel on the blast furnace and basic oxygen furnace route, the path that burns this coal.

FY26 COKING COAL, COAL MINISTRY TALLY

ItemMillion tonnes
Total requirement72.26
Imports66.33
Washed domestic output5.93
Australia27.32
United States9.91
Russia9.25
Other origins19.85

Australian hard coking coal, at 8-10 per cent ash, still dominates the quality end of that table. The draft National Steel Policy put Australian hard coking coal at $278 a tonne FOB in September 2026, against an average of $236 a tonne in January-July 2026. An EY November report, using the same 66.33 million tonne consumption figure, said import needs could rise to around 85-90 million tonnes by FY30, and could touch 112 million tonnes if capacity growth stays heavy on blast furnaces and domestic supply lags. India produced 170.15 million tonnes of crude steel in FY26, up from 152.18 million tonnes in FY25 and 144.30 million tonnes in FY23. More steel on this route means more of the same imported coke diet.

Angul’s New Furnaces Need That Imported Coal

Jindal is not describing someone else’s build-out. On March 24, 2026, Jindal Steel said it had doubled Angul to 12 million tonnes a year by starting a third 3 million tonne basic oxygen furnace, taking group crude steel capacity to 15.6 million tonnes including 3.6 million tonnes at Raigarh. On September 26, 2025, the company blew in a 5 million tonne blast furnace at the same Odisha complex, lifting hot metal capacity from 4 million tonnes a year to 9 million. Those are coke ovens and furnaces, not electric-arc shops waiting on scrap.

He has been open about why the route still wins inside India. Newer blast furnaces, he said, have cut coke use from around 600 kilogrammes per tonne of hot metal to around 350 kg, with the industry working toward about 300 kg, the rest coming from pulverized coal injection, gas and, later, hydrogen. Efficiency trims the recipe. It does not retire the oven. He also said blast furnaces will stay important because of their output and because of the steel India’s roads, rail and housing still want, a point he tied to the national targets of 300 million tonnes of steel capacity by 2030-31 and 600 million tonnes by 2047.

The Coal Ministry’s own import-substitution arithmetic sits behind those tonnes. It estimates India will need about 161 million tonnes of coking coal by 2030-31 to support a 300 million tonne steel target, including 181 million tonnes a year through the blast furnace route. Spare cargoes from a slower Europe help only if those cargoes still sail, and if Indian ports and blends can take them. They do not rewrite a 161 million tonne demand line.

Washeries Aim for 30% Domestic Blend by 2030

Mission Coking Coal, launched by the Coal Ministry, aims to lift domestic 140 million tonnes of raw coking coal by FY 2029-30, with 105 million tonnes from Coal India and 35 million tonnes from other allocated blocks. Raw output is the headline. Washed coal is the product mills can actually charge. The draft National Steel Policy puts operational washing capacity at about 39 million tonnes a year, with about 17 million tonnes of feed yielding about 6 million tonnes of washed coal, a recovery near 30 per cent. Jindal told the summit that replacing even 25-30 per cent of requirements with domestic supply would strengthen the sector. The mission’s blend target is the same neighbourhood: about 10 per cent domestic coal in the steel blend now, 30 per cent by FY 2030, helped by stamp-charging so more high-ash coal can enter the coke mix without wrecking strength.

MISSION COKING COAL, AS OF THE JULY 2026 LOK SABHA REPLY

  • New washeries: Two units totalling 7.5 million tonnes a year have been commissioned since FY 2022, and seven more totalling 19.5 million tonnes a year are planned by Coal India for FY 2030.
  • Old plants: One existing washery of 2 million tonnes a year has been monetized, with revival and modernisation listed for other ageing units.
  • Blocks and mines: Twenty-two coking coal blocks have been auctioned, and 11 discontinued Coal India mines have been offered to private operators on revenue share.
  • Blend tools: Stamp charging is being pushed so more domestic coal can enter the coke oven, and a steel-using-coking-coal washery-developer window was added to non-regulated linkage auctions in March 2024.
  • Odisha gap: No coking coal-bearing area has been identified, and no coking coal block has been allocated, in Odisha, the state that now hosts Angul’s 12 million tonne mill.

Anil Kumar Chaudhary, former chairman of Steel Authority of India, has called coking coal one of the biggest constraints on the industry, a large slice of cost and a live exposure to foreign prices and shipping. Complete import substitution, he has said, is neither realistic nor necessary; domestic coal has to contribute a larger share of the blend. That is a narrower ambition than Jindal’s picture of tonnes freed by Europe, and it is the one the washery programme is actually built to hit.

Europe’s Carbon Border Already Taxes Blast-Furnace Steel

The same Western turn Jindal called a good point for coal supply is already a bill for Indian steel that still travels on the blast-furnace route. The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism entered its definitive period on January 1, 2026. On November 16, 2026, the European Commission adopted rules on carbon prices already paid abroad, so an importer can deduct a verified carbon price paid in a non-EU country when surrendering CBAM certificates. India’s own carbon market is only beginning to set a number. At the conclave, McKinsey’s Amit Aggarwal put indicative Indian CCTS prices at Rs 1,000-1,500 per tonne of CO2, against €80-100 per tonne under CBAM. The gap is the surcharge on coal-made steel that still wants a European buyer.

Jayant Acharya, joint MD and CEO of JSW Steel, told the same New Delhi meetings that developed markets are stacking tariff and non-tariff walls, that CBAM is one of them, and that those walls can also dump displaced metal back into India. He pointed to a US duty of 50 per cent on steel and to CBAM already in place. On November 16, 2026, the Commission imposed a 9.5 percent anti-dumping duty on Indian cold-rolled steel, covering JSW Steel, Tata Steel and other Indian mills, with effect from November 17. Indian steel exports in the first half of FY27 rose 38 per cent to 5.53 million tonnes, but shipments to the EU fell 26 per cent as mills sent coils and semis to the UAE, Vietnam, the UK and the United States instead.

THE DATES AROUND JINDAL’S COAL CLAIM

  1. January 1, 2026: CBAM’s definitive period begins on iron and steel entering the EU.
  2. March 24, 2026: Jindal Steel completes the Angul expansion to 12 million tonnes a year.
  3. July 29, 2026: The Coal Ministry tells the Lok Sabha that about 90 per cent of steel’s coking coal still arrives from abroad.
  4. November 16-17, 2026: Brussels sets a 9.5 per cent anti-dumping duty on Indian cold-rolled flat steel and publishes CBAM rules on foreign carbon prices.
  5. November 18, 2026: Jindal tells the ISA Coking Coal Summit that Europe’s post-2035 furnace exit will leave India enough coal.

Europe’s own conversion is slower than the 2035 line on a slide. Thyssenkrupp has pushed the start of its Duisburg hydrogen-ready direct-reduction plant from 2027 to 2029. ArcelorMittal earlier halted planned DRI-EAF plants in Germany. If those delays hold, the surplus Jindal is counting on arrives later, while the border charge is already in force. Dilip Oommen of AMNS India put another cost on the Indian side of that ledger: duties and levies not folded into GST add 8 to 12 per cent in unrecoverable embedded costs, against 1 to 2 per cent in the EU, Japan and Korea. SAIL chairman Ashok Kumar Panda told the conclave that hydrogen in blast furnaces and carbon capture are not yet economical in India. The cheap leftover coal, if it comes, will still make a steel that Europe prices as dirty.

India as Residual Buyer After 2035

Jindal may be right that seaborne coking coal will look looser once European blast furnaces go cold. He may also be describing a market in which India is the last large customer still willing to sign for those cargoes, at whatever ash, freight and carbon price the trade then clears. Narendran’s same-day warning is the plainer constraint: Indian reserves will not cover Indian steel, in tonnes or in grade, so the import line stays open even if Europe walks off it.

The washery mission, the Mozambique tonnes, and the drop in Australia’s share from 73 per cent in 2019 to 54 per cent in 2025 are the tools India actually has. They shave a blend. They do not retire a 66.33 million tonne invoice. After 2035, if Jindal’s calendar holds, the coal will be there for the furnaces India is still lighting. The bill for lighting them, at the mine gate and at the European border, will be there too.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending