Connect with us

NEWS

Lahore Court Puts Ishaq Dar’s Grandson Back on Rape Charge

A Lahore judge indicted Ishaq Dar’s grandson and seven others for rape after police had named three staffers instead. The two complainants have left Pakistan.

Published

on

A Lahore court on November 10 framed rape charges against eight men, including Muhammad Raza Dar, grandson of Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar. All eight pleaded not guilty. Additional District and Sessions Judge Rafaqat Ali Gondal told prosecutors to produce witnesses on December 10.

Seven days earlier, Punjab police had told the same court they had no rape evidence against Dar and four others, and had named three of his staff instead. Those staffers are still in the case. The two women who accused the group are not. They left Pakistan on July 3.

All Eight Men Now Face the Rape Charge

Jail staff produced the accused in judicial custody for the indictment. A court official said Gondal framed the charges and set December 10 for the first prosecution witnesses. An indictment is not a verdict. It is the point at which the trial court tells each accused what he must answer, after police have already filed their version of the facts.

The FIR sits at Defence C police station. It was recorded in July under sections covering kidnapping for ransom in the Penal Code, rape, concealing a kidnapped person, causing evidence to disappear, and other hurt. Separate files were opened under the Arms Ordinance after pistols and a rifle were seized.

The political name on the file is why the hearing is watched. Dar is described throughout the police papers as the grandson of Ishaq Dar, who is also foreign minister. The hidden weight of the file is elsewhere. Three low-paid men police wrote up as the rapists remain among the eight. Two foreign complainants who already gave magistrate statements are due to be the trial’s main voices, and they have been outside the country since early July.

Why Police Charged Three Staffers With Rape

The incomplete challan filed on November 3 did not clear the whole case. It cleared five men of sexual assault and kept them on illegal detention and extortion. It named three other suspects, described as low-paid employees of one of the main accused, as the men who raped the women. Police wrote that the complainants’ statements and the inquiry pointed to those three, and that they had found no rape evidence against the other five, including Dar and a man the file called “boss”.

We found no evidence of rape against the other five suspects, including Raza Dar.

Punjab Police investigation report, submitted November 3, 2026

Advocate Salman Shahid, who represents two of the men charged with sexual assault, accused police of protecting the main suspects. He said his clients were low-paid employees of one of those suspects and had been made scapegoats. One, he said, worked on the janitorial staff at the property where the alleged assault took place.

That claim sits beside an earlier forensic leak. On July 6, investigation sources said DNA from eight suspects had gone to a lab and that three samples had matched evidence from one of the women. They named Nawaz as the first match, and Sajid and Sikandar as the other two. Nawaz had been produced days earlier with Rizwan and Nasir as a security guard. A judicial magistrate, Azhar Mahmood, had given those three a five-day physical remand and refused a 14-day police request.

MEN NAMED IN THE JULY PRODUCTIONS

  • Raza Dar: Produced with three others before Magistrate Azhar Mahmood, who ordered the men to remove face masks for identification.
  • Hassan Raza, Sajid Ali, Sikander Khan: Produced in the same batch; Sajid and Sikandar were later named among the DNA matches.
  • Nawaz, Rizwan, Nasir: Produced as security guards; Nawaz was also accused of rape and later named as the top DNA match.

The November challan never printed those three DNA names as the three staffers. The article does not collapse them. What the court did on November 10 was simpler than police had tried to make it. Gondal put all eight men, including Dar, back onto the rape charge the original FIR had carried.

Two Complainants Already Left Pakistan

The complainants are Stephanie Adnana Mau-Arun, a Dutch national, and Astrid Robinson Baracho, a Venezuelan national. Police say they met Dar in Singapore in October 2025, invited him into a cryptocurrency venture, and later accepted his invitation to Pakistan after the money soured. He arranged their visas, the FIR says. They reached Lahore on June 29, 2026.

Medical examinations confirmed both women had been raped, police told the court. Each recorded a statement under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which allows statements recorded before a magistrate during an investigation, then left on July 3.

The FIR, as read out in July, is the closest public record of what they said happened inside the house. Baracho alleged she was raped by one suspect and sexually assaulted by two others and was threatened with a knife. Mau-Arun alleged she fought off an attempted rape, was forced into oral sex, was stripped, and was threatened with shards of a broken mirror. Both said their captors threatened to kill them and sell their organs if a $1.5 million demand was not met.

Lahore DIG Operations Faisal Kamran said in early July that police had been ordered to treat a suspect linked to a senior minister like “any other criminal,” and that a “criminal gang” might sit behind the incident. He said Safe City cameras tracked a vehicle onto the motorway toward Sargodha, with raids in Shahdara and Defence. Four suspects were arrested on July 2 after phones, the vehicle, and location data were traced.

The first ransom call, Kamran said, came on July 1 from a man identified as Carlos, who also said Spanish authorities had been told. The same day, the women escaped. Police say a car taking them to the airport crashed near Bhatta Chowk, they jumped out and hid in a filter house, and officers took them into protection. The relative named in the file fled the scene, the November challan says. South Cantt police registered a separate collision case after a driver named Usman reported being hit on Airport Road.

In July, investigators said the women had declined to hand over their own phones for forensic work, while the suspects’ phones had been sent in. Officials then spoke of questioning them by video if needed. No public file since the indictment says whether that will happen on December 10.

The Incomplete Challan Did Not Bind the Judge

Gondal had already handed copies of the November 3 report to the accused and listed November 11 for the next date. The indictment came a day earlier than that listing. Police had asked the court to summon the men by notice and had filed an incomplete challan on purpose. DNA, fingerprint, and polygraph tests had been done, and call records had been pulled, but Punjab Forensic Science Agency reports were still awaited, the filing said, and police did not want to wait.

Another man in the file is accused of renting the house without telling the authorities. A further suspect is accused of helping destroy evidence. Those two allegations are why sections 368 and 201 were added.

HOW THE RAPE CHARGE MOVED

GroupPolice challan, November 3Court indictment, November 10
Raza Dar and four associatesRape dropped; detention and extortion keptRape and kidnapping charges framed
Three staffersNamed as the men who committed rapeIncluded in the same eight-man indictment
All eight accusedIncomplete challan; forensic agency reports awaitedPleaded not guilty; produced from judicial custody

Kamran’s July promise that no legal gap would be left for the well-connected suspect is now the record the trial will test. Police spent four months building a split theory: rape for the staff, detention and extortion for Dar’s circle. The sessions court declined to try the case on that split.

Sheikh Waqas Akram, a PTI member of parliament, had already called in July for a swift investigation “without any political protection or delay.” The November indictment answers part of that demand by putting Dar back on the rape count. It does not take the staffers out.

A $500,000 Crypto Dispute and a $19,500 Transfer

Every police version of this case starts as a business fight. The women, the challan says, met one of the prime suspects in Singapore in 2025 and asked him to put money into their cryptocurrency work. He took a profit on a first slice, then put in more than $500,000. This time, police say, they paid no profit and did not return the stake.

He then invited them to Pakistan, the report says, on the pretext of a meeting with another investor. They stayed at an Islamabad hotel and went to Murree and other places of their own will, police wrote. The suspect then told an associate the women owed him money. The associate brought in the man the file calls “boss.” On June 29 they were taken to a house in Defence Phase VII, Lahore, held, and pressed to pay.

THREE SUMS IN THE POLICE FILE

  • The FIR demand: $1.5 million, with threats to kill the women and sell body parts if it was not paid.
  • The transfer on the challan: about $19,500, forced from the women, converted into rupees through a Lahore account, with Rs1.1 million each going to two suspects.
  • The recovery: Rs4.3 million that police say was extorted, plus a mobile phone and a vehicle used in the crime.

Those three figures are not the same pot of money. The $1.5 million is the ransom the FIR says was demanded. The $19,500 is the sum police say actually moved. The Rs4.3 million is what officers say they later recovered. Armed men, the challan says, guarded the house and threatened the women with a knife, a gun, and a piece of broken mirror.

What Section 375A Means in This Case

The rape count on the FIR is not the older standalone rape section alone. Defence C registered the case under section 375-A as well as 365-A. A 2021 amendment that created the offence of gang rape added 375A to the Pakistan Penal Code. The official text of gang rape under section 375A says that where a person is raped by one or more persons acting as a group or in furtherance of a common intention, each of them is guilty of gang rape.

The punishment listed is death, or imprisonment for the remainder of natural life, or imprisonment for life, and a fine. The offence is non-bailable and not compoundable, and it is tried in a court of sessions. That is the charge Gondal has now attached to all eight men, including the three staffers and the five police had tried to take off it.

SECTIONS ON THE DEFENCE C FIR

  • 365-A: Kidnapping or abducting to extort property or a valuable security; death or life imprisonment; non-bailable.
  • 375-A: Gang rape; death, remainder of natural life, or life, and a fine.
  • 368 and 201: Wrongfully keeping a kidnapped person, and causing evidence of an offence to disappear; added for the alleged house rental and the alleged clean-up.
  • 337-L(II): Other hurt, the injury count attached to the same FIR.

That is not a finding that any of the eight did what the FIR describes. All eight have pleaded not guilty. The prosecution now has to call witnesses to a sessions trial in which the two central complainants live in the Netherlands and Venezuela.

December 10 Is When Witnesses Must Appear

THE DATES IN THE LAHORE CASE

  1. October 2025: The women meet Dar in Singapore and, police say, bring him into a cryptocurrency venture.
  2. June 29, 2026: They arrive in Lahore on visas he arranged and are taken to a house in Defence Phase VII.
  3. July 1, 2026: A ransom call is logged; a car crashes near Bhatta Chowk; the women escape and police take them into protection.
  4. July 2, 2026: Four suspects are arrested after phones, a vehicle, and location data are traced.
  5. July 3, 2026: Both women leave Pakistan after medical exams and Section 164 statements.
  6. July 6, 2026: Investigation sources say DNA from Nawaz, Sajid, and Sikandar has matched; five other samples are still pending.
  7. November 3, 2026: Police file an incomplete challan that drops rape against five men and names three staffers for the assault.
  8. November 10, 2026: Gondal frames charges against all eight; they plead not guilty.
  9. December 10, 2026: Prosecution witnesses are due to be recorded.

Thirty days separate the indictment from that witness date. Four months already separate the women from the city where the trial will be heard. Their magistrate statements are on the file. Whether they will sit in a Lahore courtroom, appear on a screen, or stay in the paper record is not a question the November 10 hearing answered.

The staffers Shahid called scapegoats will be in the dock either way. So will Raza Dar. The two women who started the case boarded flights out of Pakistan on July 3.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending