Connect with us

NEWS

Indian-American Democrats Hold House Seats as Ramaswamy Falls

Vivek Ramaswamy lost Ohio by 234,331 votes while Indian-American Democrats held House seats and Pia Dandiya won Florida, a party-line split not a diaspora wave.

Published

on

Vivek Ramaswamy lost the Ohio governor’s race on Tuesday by 234,331 votes, unofficial statewide returns showed, as Indian-American Democrats held House seats on a night Democrats took Congress. Amy Acton, a physician and former state health director, had 51.1 percent (2,167,087 votes) to his 45.6 percent (1,932,756) with 89.3 percent of the expected vote counted.

Decision Desk HQ projected Democrats had won the Senate after flipping Republican-held seats in Texas, Kansas, South Carolina, Ohio, Iowa and North Carolina, and projected a Democratic House as well. Indian-American names were on both tickets. Party, not ancestry, sorted them.

Vivek Ramaswamy Loses the Ohio Governor’s Race

Libertarian Don Kissick took 3.3 percent (141,792 votes) in the same unofficial statewide count. The 5.5-point gap was already past what Ramaswamy could close. Acton, 60, will be the first woman elected governor of Ohio. Nancy Hollister served 11 days in 1999 after George Voinovich left for the Senate, but voters had never chosen a woman for the office. Acton is also the first Democrat to win it since Ted Strickland in 2006, a 20-year wait in a state Donald Trump carried in three straight presidential races.

Ramaswamy, 41, had Trump’s endorsement, and strategists from Trump’s and Vice President JD Vance’s teams advised him and an aligned super PAC. He still lost. Trump campaigned for him on Oct. 3 in Vandalia, near Dayton, and did not hide the 2024 primary fight. “He was not easy. This one was not easy. He was a nasty guy. But you know what? He was smart. He loves the state. He’s actually got a great heart,” Trump said.

The closing stretch turned on a $4 million ad. About two weeks before Election Day, Ramaswamy’s campaign put Acton’s mother, Donna Arthur, on television calling her daughter a liar and telling Ohioans not to vote for her. Acton has said she has not seen or spoken with Arthur in nearly 50 years and has accused her mother’s then-husband of sexually abusing her as a child. Gov. Mike DeWine, a Republican, and other Republicans condemned the spot. Ramaswamy refused to pull it or apologize.

Because of your hard work, Ohio has chosen unity and decency over division and hate. The healing begins today. We must never give up on one another. This was a tough race, but the campaign is over, and I want to make something very clear to the people of Ohio. I will be a governor for all Ohioans. I am in this fight for all of us.

Amy Acton, victory speech, Columbus

Ramaswamy told his own room in Columbus it had been “a tough race” and “bitter at times, in both directions.” He said he hoped Acton could “bring Ohio together, to bring our voters and our citizens together, to lead Ohio to the best place possible.” Acton had refused to debate him. Her campaign manager said she had no interest in “platforming a scam artist.”

She talked about growing up poor in Youngstown and treated his wealth as a problem while prices stayed high, including the private jet he used to hop Ohio cities. Fellow Republicans groused about the jet. He poured his own money into the race, and a super PAC backing him took millions of dollars from Elon Musk and Jeffrey Yass, the super PAC’s FEC raising data show. Acton had served as DeWine’s health director early in Covid, which made her famous and, for Republicans, a target over school and business closures. DeWine later said those attacks were unfair. She will succeed term-limited DeWine.

Unofficial Ohio election-night returns stay unofficial until the secretary of state certifies the canvass, about three weeks after Election Day. The argument on the right after the race was called was not about Indian-American clout. It was whether Ramaswamy had been a weak nominee, whether Trump’s brand had sunk the Ohio ticket, and, from some corners, whether his heritage had been a drag in a mostly white, Christian state. He had already said online racism was bad enough that he deleted social apps from his phone.

A Florida Breakthrough and the Safe House Seats

Pia Dandiya, 39, won Florida’s 22nd Congressional District with 51.9 percent against Republican Casey Askar, a Marine veteran. She is the first Indian American elected to the House from Florida. Born and raised in Palm Beach County to parents who immigrated from India, she taught, ran a high school in Harlem, later worked as a White House Fellow and at Apple, and ran on housing, insurance, health costs and schools.

Suhas Subramanyam, 40, won a second term in Virginia’s 10th District with 63.16 percent (173,106 votes) against Republican Dave Beckwith’s 34.66 percent (94,990). Independent Ahsen Malik was also on the ballot. Subramanyam, born in Houston to Indian parents, advised President Barack Obama on technology policy, then won a Virginia House of Delegates seat in 2019 as the first Indian American and Hindu in that legislature. He is the first Indian American sent to Congress from the East Coast.

Pramila Jayapal held Washington’s 7th District in a landslide, 87.5 percent (177,700 votes) to 12.1 percent (24,654) for Republican Nirav Sheth, a Gujarat-born former Marine. Jayapal, born in Chennai and in the House since 2017, was the first Indian-American woman elected to the chamber. Ro Khanna was projected to hold California’s 17th District in Silicon Valley against Republican Ritesh Tandon, an Indian-American entrepreneur. Unofficial returns with 43.9 percent of the expected vote in had Khanna at 70.9 percent (69,236) and Tandon at 29.1 percent (28,448), a lead of 40,788 votes. Ami Bera, the longest-serving Indian American in the House, led Republican Robb Tucker 59.3 percent (85,629) to 40.7 percent (58,691) in California’s 3rd District with 42.7 percent of the expected vote in. That race had not been called.

Aruna Miller won another term as Maryland lieutenant governor on the ticket with Gov. Wes Moore, who beat Republican Dan Cox. Miller was born in Hyderabad in 1964, moved to the United States at age 7, and earned a civil engineering degree from the Missouri University of Science and Technology in 1989.

INDIAN-AMERICAN RESULTS AFTER TUESDAY’S VOTE

CandidateRaceStatusShare
Vivek Ramaswamy (R)Ohio governorLost45.6% (1,932,756)
Pia Dandiya (D)Florida 22nd HouseWon51.9%
Suhas Subramanyam (D)Virginia 10th HouseWon63.16% (173,106)
Pramila Jayapal (D)Washington 7th HouseWon87.5% (177,700)
Ro Khanna (D)California 17th HouseProjected hold70.9% (69,236), 43.9% in
Ami Bera (D)California 3rd HouseLeading, uncalled59.3% (85,629), 42.7% in
Amish Shah (D)Arizona 1st HouseLeading, uncalled54.9% (141,631), 72.4% in
Aruna Miller (D)Maryland lieutenant governorWonRe-elected with Wes Moore
Nithya Raman (D)Los Angeles mayorTrailing, uncalled49.3% (289,904)
Saritha Komatireddy (R)New York attorney generalLostLost to Letitia James

Those House holds sat inside a national flip. All 435 House seats, 37 of 100 Senate seats, and 36 governorships were on the ballot. Republicans had entered the night with 53 Senate seats and a House of 218 Republicans, 214 Democrats, one independent and two vacancies. Democrats needed a net gain of four Senate seats and 218 House seats for control. They got the projection for both. The last time the party out of the White House took both chambers on one night was 2006, the same year Ohio last elected a Democratic governor.

Two Primary Defeats Were Already Shrinking the Group

The informal cluster of Indian-American House Democrats, nicknamed the Samosa Caucus by Raja Krishnamoorthi after the 2016 wave, had six members when the 119th Congress opened in January 2025, all Democrats: Bera, Khanna, Jayapal, Krishnamoorthi, Shri Thanedar and Subramanyam. That was the high-water mark. It was already going to fall before a single November ballot was scanned.

WHO LEAVES THE HOUSE IN JANUARY

  • Raja Krishnamoorthi: He gave up Illinois’s 8th District to run for Senate and lost the March 17 Democratic primary to Lt. Gov. Juliana Stratton, 40.39 percent to 32.71 percent.
  • Shri Thanedar: He lost the Aug. 4 Democratic primary in Michigan’s 13th District to state Rep. Donavan McKinney, 51.9 percent to 48.1 percent.

Ancestry did not save either man in a party fight. Krishnamoorthi would have been only the second Indian American elected to the Senate, after Kamala Harris, if he had won in November. Thanedar, born in Karnataka, had reached the House in 2023 after a chemistry Ph.D. and a career building a drug company. Primary voters ended both paths.

That left four incumbents on the November ballot in districts that lean Democratic, plus two challengers who could replace the departed. Dandiya’s Florida win is one replacement. Amish Shah’s lead in Arizona would be the other. If Bera’s lead holds and Shah wins, the group is six again in January. If Shah falls, it is five. It cannot grow past six this cycle. No other Indian-American House nominee was in a race that even looked close.

The nickname is a joke that stuck, not a whip operation. Members share notes, sign letters on hate crimes, visas and the U.S.-India relationship, and show up together at community events. They do not vote as a bloc. Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the phrase in a joint meeting of Congress in June 2023 and said he hoped it would grow. Tuesday did not grow it. Tuesday backfilled it.

Khanna and Jayapal Beat Indian-American Republicans

Two ballots put Indian Americans in both parties’ columns, and both races were over before they started. Tandon, a Silicon Valley entrepreneur on his fourth run in California’s 17th, reported $5,227 in cash on Oct. 14. Khanna had $16,936,477 on Sept. 30. Tandon had raised $57,011 for the cycle, with no party money. Sheth, a Lakewood police officer, reported $5,043.77 in cash and $8,900 raised in 2026. Jayapal had $1,767,956 in the bank.

Those filings are the tell. Heritage on both sides of a House race sounds like a milestone. The money says the Republican nominees were protest candidacies in deep-blue seats. Khanna’s district includes parts of Silicon Valley. Jayapal’s covers Seattle. Trump-era Indian-American Republicans still do not have a House farm team that can fund a real challenge to the Democrats who already hold these seats.

Mahesh Ganorkar, another Indian-American Republican, lost in North Carolina’s 4th District against Democratic Rep. Valerie Foushee, a seat treated as safely Democratic. Independent Sandeep Dixit lost in Ohio and independent Anil Kumar lost in Michigan. Saritha Komatireddy, a former federal prosecutor, lost the New York attorney general’s race to incumbent Democrat Letitia James. The Republican of Indian origin who had a real statewide machine, Trump’s backing, and his own fortune was Ramaswamy. He is the one who lost by 234,331 votes.

Dalip Singh Saund Waited Four Decades for a Successor

The House group sits on a thin older line. Dalip Singh Saund, a Punjab-born farmer in California’s Imperial Valley, became the first Asian American elected to Congress in 1956 and took his seat in 1957. He had to win the right to naturalize first. President Harry Truman signed the 1946 law that let Indian and Filipino immigrants become citizens. Saund became a citizen in 1949, fought to serve as a judge, then won a Republican-leaning district and joined the House Foreign Affairs Committee as a freshman. A stroke in 1962 ended the job. He left office in 1963.

INDIAN AMERICANS IN THE HOUSE

  1. 1956: Saund wins a California House seat, the first Indian American and first Asian American in Congress, and serves from 1957 to 1963.
  2. 2004: Bobby Jindal, a Louisiana Republican, wins a House seat and serves from 2005 to 2008, then resigns to become governor.
  3. 2012: Ami Bera, a Sacramento physician, wins, the first Indian American in the House in decades, and says he hopes to see ten there someday.
  4. 2016: Khanna, Krishnamoorthi and Jayapal join Bera; Harris wins a Senate seat. Krishnamoorthi later coins “Samosa Caucus.”
  5. 2023: Thanedar enters the House from Detroit.
  6. 2025: Subramanyam is sworn in from Virginia’s 10th, and the group hits six.

After Saund, more than 40 years passed before Jindal. After Jindal’s short House stay, Bera was alone until the 2016 cycle. The rise was real, and it was almost entirely Democratic. Nikki Haley and Ramaswamy ran in the 2024 Republican presidential primary, which is the other half of the community’s politics. Haley was not on a 2026 ballot. Ramaswamy was, in the one race that would have given an Indian-American Republican a governor’s office in a big state. Ohio said no.

The Open Arizona Seat Still Has No Winner

Amish Shah, an emergency-room physician and former Arizona state representative, led Republican Jay Feely 54.9 percent (141,631 votes) to 43.3 percent (111,699) in Arizona’s 1st District, with Libertarian Monica Alponte at 1.9 percent (4,840), and 72.4 percent of the expected vote in. The lead was 29,932 votes. The race had not been called. Feely, a former NFL kicker with Trump’s endorsement, did not concede. He told supporters the early numbers were disappointing and that climbing out would be hard, and said he was at peace either way.

The seat is open because Republican David Schweikert left it to run for governor and lost. Trump carried the district by about 3 points in 2024. Shah lost to Schweikert in 2024 by 3.8 points, then won a 2026 Democratic primary over Marlene Galán-Woods, the choice of the national House campaign arm, 39.4 percent (29,002) to 34.4 percent. Feely won his primary with 49.8 percent (43,709) after switching from the 5th District when Trump pushed him toward the 1st. Outside groups poured about $25 million into the race. Feely called Shah a socialist. Shah called Feely a Trump loyalist. If Shah’s lead holds, he becomes one of the few Indian-American House members in a district Republicans still carry at the presidential line.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • Called holds: Subramanyam, Jayapal and Dandiya have won House races; Khanna is a projected hold; Miller is back as Maryland lieutenant governor.
  • Called loss: Ramaswamy has lost Ohio; Komatireddy has lost the New York attorney general’s race.
  • National map: Decision Desk HQ has projected Democratic control of the Senate and the House for the last two years of Trump’s term.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • Arizona 1st: Shah leads Feely by 29,932 votes with 72.4 percent in; no projection, no concession.
  • California 3rd: Bera leads with 42.7 percent of the expected vote counted.
  • Los Angeles mayor: Nithya Raman trails Karen Bass by 8,086 votes with about half the expected vote in.

Pooja Sethi, a Democratic attorney and former Texas legislative chief of staff, was still in the count in Texas House District 47. Sandeep Srivastava, a Plano-Frisco businessman, was still in Texas House District 66 against a five-term Republican. At the state legislative level, Democrat Arvind Venkat won re-election in Pennsylvania’s House District 30 and Ram Villivalam held Illinois Senate District 8. Nabeela Syed led Republican incumbent Darby Hills in Illinois Senate District 26. Jyot Singh led Republican Yassin Moghazy in Georgia House District 97.

Los Angeles Leaves Raman Just Behind Bass

Nithya Raman, a Los Angeles city councilmember and urban planner born in Kerala, trailed Mayor Karen Bass 49.3 percent (289,904) to 50.7 percent (297,990) with about 50 percent of the expected vote in. Bass’s edge was 8,086 votes. The race is a runoff after a June primary in which Bass had 34.27 percent, Raman 29.02 percent and reality-television figure Spencer Pratt 25.53 percent. A UC Berkeley Institute of Governmental Studies poll released Oct. 28, with 19 percent still undecided, had Bass and Raman tied at 40 percent among likely voters, after Raman’s earlier double-digit lead vanished. Pratt did not endorse.

Raman co-founded a neighborhood homelessness coalition and co-chaired a Silver Lake committee on the same issue. Bass rebuilt support among Black voters and in the San Fernando Valley in that late poll, and among people who had backed Pratt. Mail ballots still to be counted can move a 8,086-vote citywide race. It had not been called.

Tuesday’s Indian-American ledger is a Democratic House night, a lost Republican governorship, and a caucus that only stays near six because two members were already gone. Dandiya’s Florida seat is a first. Shah’s Arizona lead, if it survives the rest of the count, would put an Indian-American Democrat in a district Trump carried. Ramaswamy had the money, the endorsement and the national name, and still finished 234,331 votes behind Acton. The names on the ballots were Indian American. The sorting was American party politics.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending