Connect with us

NEWS

Supreme Court Says Don’t Fly While Festival Fares Stay Uncapped

The Supreme Court refused an urgent Diwali airfare listing while new rules wait until January and existing tariff powers sit unused.

Published

on

The Supreme Court on November 2, 2026 refused to list an urgent plea on Diwali airfares, and told the lawyer not to fly. Advocate Abhinav, mentioning an interim application for social activist S. Laxminarayanan, said domestic fares had risen to 700% of normal and that air travel was an essential service protected by Article 14.

Don’t travel by air. Next case, Justice Vikram Nath said, sitting with Justices Sandeep Mehta and Aparesh Kumar Singh. The full petition is already listed for November 16. New aviation rules, published in the Official Gazette on October 31, take effect on January 1, 2027.

The Same Bench Called Festival Fares Exploitation

Nath and Mehta are not new to this file. On January 19, 2026 they were hearing Laxminarayanan’s public interest petition, W.P.(C) No. 1124/2025, which seeks an independent regulator and binding guidelines on “unpredictable fluctuations” in fares and extra charges. Additional Solicitor General Anil Kaushik was in court for the Centre.

We will definitely interfere. Just see the exploitation during the Kumbh and other festivals. Just see the fares from Delhi to Prayagraj and Jodhpur, three times the normal.

Justice Vikram Nath, oral observation, Supreme Court of India, January 19, 2026

Nath added that the spike was not confined to the Kumbh. “Not only Kumbh, but every festival,” he said that day. The bench asked the Centre and the Directorate General of Civil Aviation to file replies and listed the matter for February 23. Notices had already gone to the Union, the DGCA and the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India on November 17, 2025.

The January remarks were oral, not an order capping tickets. They still sit on the same case that Abhinav tried to jump forward on November 2. What he brought was not a fresh writ. It was an interlocutory application, filed on October 30, asking for a festival-season cap and for economy checked baggage to return from 15 kg to 25 kg while the main petition waits.

A Delhi-Kolkata Ticket Hit ₹78,694

The 700% figure was the advocate’s oral claim, “increased to 700% of normal.” The papers underneath it are more specific. The application says fares on several busy domestic routes rose between two and seven times ordinary levels ahead of Diwali, and it puts rupee examples against travel on November 6, which is Dhanteras. Main Diwali is November 8.

FARES CITED IN THE OCTOBER 30 APPLICATION

Route and comparisonLower cited fareHigher cited fare
Delhi-Kolkata, ordinary vs November 6₹10,000-₹11,000₹78,694
Bengaluru-Delhi, November 6, 5 am vs 3:45 pm₹15,901₹40,506
Mumbai-Delhi₹11,531₹60,577
Delhi-Mumbai₹5,223₹26,793

Against the upper ordinary figure, ₹78,694 is about seven times a Delhi-Kolkata ticket. The same-day Bengaluru-Delhi pair is about two and a half times, which is the example the application uses to attack the fuel story. Mumbai-Delhi and Delhi-Mumbai in those papers sit at about five times.

Airlines, the application says, blame aviation turbine fuel, and the Union has repeated that line. “It does not bear scrutiny,” the filing says. “The fuel burnt by the 5:00 AM and the 3:45 PM flight on the same route and day is the same, yet one fare is over two and a half times the other.” It adds that at a July 13, 2026 hearing the court had already heard fuel and geopolitics used to defend jumps of 100% to 300%, “though the impact of fuel on cost is small.”

A person who must get home for a festival, or travel at short notice for illness, death or work, “has no choice but to fly and to pay whatever is demanded,” the application says. Confirmed festival trains, it says, are gone weeks ahead. Rail flexi fare, it notes, is capped at one and a half times the base fare. Festival travellers then pay excess baggage on top of the ticket because the free allowance has fallen from 25 kg to 15 kg.

That is the bind the quip does not answer. If the berth is gone and the fare is five or seven times the ordinary ticket, “don’t travel by air” is an instruction to miss the festival.

New Fare Rules Sit Until January

The timing is tighter than the joke. On October 16, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told a bench that included Nath that the rules under the 2024 civil aviation statute had administrative approval and would be published in two weeks. The court asked him to place the published text on the next date, November 16.

The Bharatiya Vayuyan Adhiniyam, 2024, Act 16 of 2024, came into force on January 1, 2025 and replaced the Aircraft Act, 1934. Section 10 already lets the Centre make rules for economic regulation of air transport, including the approval, disapproval or revision of tariff charged by operators, other than airport charges that sit with the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority.

The Bharatiya Vayuyan Niyam, 2026, were published in the Official Gazette on October 31. They replace the Aircraft Rules, 1937 from January 1, 2027. They do not put a ceiling on Diwali 2026 tickets, and they do not treat a festival rush as a default trigger.

WHAT RULE 192 REQUIRES FROM JANUARY

  • Who sets the fare: Scheduled airlines still fix tariffs with regard to operating costs and related factors, then file those tariffs with the DGCA in the form and at the intervals the regulator specifies.
  • What passengers must see: The total amount payable has to appear on the booking site and on the ticket, broken into fare, taxes, fees, cancellation charges, refund terms and any other charge.
  • When the Centre can step in: Rule 192(6) lets the Central Government issue written directions if it holds that an extraordinary situation has arisen and intervention is needed in the public interest.
  • How long that lasts: Any such direction must be proportionate to the facts and remains in force only for the period the government names.
  • What is missing: The notified rule as publicly described does not define “extraordinary situation,” does not set a fare multiple that trips a cap, and does not require routine government approval of tickets.

Until January 1, 2027, the older Aircraft Rules, 1937 still govern. Rule 135 already tells airlines to set a reasonable tariff with regard to operating cost, the nature of the service, a reasonable profit and the generally prevailing tariff, and it has let the DGCA issue directions against an excessive or predatory tariff. The application leans on that surviving power, saved by section 43(2) of the 2024 Act, and says inaction in a foreseeable festival surge “permits extortion.”

So the new code is not the reason this festival is uncapped. The old code is still on the books. The new one, when it arrives, still leaves the hard call to a minister who must first find an “extraordinary situation.”

Parliament Already Heard That Fares Are Unregulated

That is also the government’s own description of the market. In a Rajya Sabha reply dated August 3, 2026, Minister of State Murlidhar Mohol said the 2024 Act was in force, nine sets of rules had to be recast, four had been gazetted, and the rest were still being framed. On fares, the same reply is blunt: airfares are not regulated by the government, and each operator sets a tariff under Rule 135.

Oversight, Mohol said, means watching declared ranges and, in rare cases, moving capacity or putting on a temporary cap. The reply lists those rare cases: the Covid period, the Maha Kumbh, the Pahalgam attack, and the IndiGo disruptions. Diwali 2026 is not on that list.

HOW FARE WATCH WORKS NOW

  • The unit: The DGCA Tariff Monitoring Unit checks selected 78 routes on a random basis, 72 domestic and 6 international, by looking at airline websites each month.
  • The share: Those 72 domestic routes cover about 27% of domestic traffic.
  • The test: The check is whether a fare sits outside the range the airline itself has declared, not whether the declared ceiling is fair.
  • The grievances: An “Air Fare” module on AirSewa logged 394 complaints from July to December 2025 and 315 from January through July 2026.

If an airline’s own tariff sheet already runs up to a Delhi-Kolkata fare of ₹78,694, a unit that only polices the declared range has little to flag. That is the hole the January bench said it would look at, and it is still the hole on November 2.

No Festive Fare Cap, the Minister Said

Civil Aviation Minister K. Rammohan Naidu had already closed the political door. On September 22, 2026, asked whether the government would cap fares for the coming festive season, he said it would not. Airlines would be advised to keep prices “at a reasonable level.” The government, he said, holds regular meetings with carriers and had used that channel in earlier festivals and big events.

“We definitely point it to them that during this festive season, you have to ensure that the fair prices are kept at a reasonable level so that the people who want to travel, especially in these important times, get to see the benefit,” Naidu said, speaking after UDAN agreements were signed. He pointed to the West Asia crisis and said aviation turbine fuel accounts for 40 to 43 per cent of airfares, so even a small fuel move hits the ticket.

He has taken that line before. In December 2025 he told the Lok Sabha the government could not cap fares for the entire year because demand rises in festivals “and fares rise accordingly. That is the market reality.” The ministry’s preferred tool is extra flights in the peak, plus the Tariff Monitoring Unit, plus advice to be moderate.

Advice is not a cap. The same government has put temporary stage-length caps on when it wanted to, including after the IndiGo disruptions in December 2025. It chose not to do that for this Diwali, then gazetted a 2027 rule that still refuses to define the emergency that would justify a short, written direction.

Why the Supreme Court Refused an Urgent Listing

The November 2 mention was an attempt to get interim orders before Dhanteras and Diwali, with the main petition already parked on November 16. Nath’s “next case” is, in docket terms, a refusal to jump that queue. It is also a line that will travel farther than the order sheet, because it comes from the same judge who, in January, promised to interfere with festival pricing and called the Prayagraj and Jodhpur spikes exploitation.

Abhinav’s Article 14 pitch, that a seven-times fare on an essential service is unequal treatment, did not get a hearing. The application also cites Articles 19(1)(d) and 21, and it compares air travel with medicines under the Drugs (Prices Control) Order, 2013 and with electricity tariffs set by commissions. That was not tested on November 2. The bench did not dismiss W.P.(C) No. 1124/2025. It would not take the interim plea out of turn.

THE LAXMINARAYANAN FARE CASE

  1. November 17, 2025: The Supreme Court issues notices to the Centre, the DGCA and AERA on the petition seeking an independent regulator and guidelines on fare swings and extra charges.
  2. January 19, 2026: Justices Nath and Mehta say they will interfere, call festival spikes exploitation, and seek replies, with the next date February 23.
  3. August 3, 2026: The civil aviation ministry tells the Rajya Sabha that four of nine rules under the 2024 Act are gazetted and that fares remain unregulated except in rare caps.
  4. August 17, 2026: The Centre tells the court it has fast-tracked the remaining rules.
  5. September 22, 2026: Naidu rules out a festive-season cap and says airlines will be asked to keep fares reasonable.
  6. October 16, 2026: Mehta says the rules have administrative approval and will be published in two weeks. The court lists the petition for November 16.
  7. October 30, 2026: Laxminarayanan files the interlocutory application for a festival cap and a 25 kg baggage restoration.
  8. October 31, 2026: The Bharatiya Vayuyan Niyam, 2026, appear in the Official Gazette, to commence on January 1, 2027.
  9. November 2, 2026: The bench refuses urgent listing. “Don’t travel by air. Next case.”

November 16 will be the first chance to put the gazetted Niyam on the record, which is what the court asked for on October 16. By then Dhanteras will have passed and Diwali will be eight days gone. Tickets already sold at the fares in the application will have been flown, cancelled, or skipped under the 1937 rules, not the 2026 ones.

Harry is the editor of NEWS ANALYSIS. He writes across the publication's ten desks, with most of his time going to the stories where a number, a filing or a study decides the argument. His working rule is simple: read the source document before writing about it, and tell the reader plainly which parts are established and which are somebody's claim. He is responsible for the standards set out on this site's Editorial Standards and Fact Checking pages, and for correcting the record openly when the publication gets something wrong.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending